skiptracer
16May12
what others have you seen? he has made some utterly amazing films.
too few people have seen Crocodile, sadly. it's such a crucial reference to his cinematic themes. & that underwater sequence at the end is a gorgeous watercolour painting w/ film, of love & redemption (w/out pushing it).
I love The Isle, The Bow and Samaria but I'm not really interested in most of his other movies. Spring Summer had some beautiful moments but mostly obvious. 3-Iron was painfully facile. At least he tackles many things in current Korean culture/society... though I would argue that a lot of Korean directors are doing this incredible blind brashlness. I think he is much much much much much more suited to making films in hermetic/reclusive settings.
Blue K is in line with Tony Rayns' provocative attack on Kim in Film Comment a few years back. I agree to an extent. The early films aren't that great, but The Isle and Bad Guy are excellent, and I also really like Samaritan Girl. I've only see Time (about the plastic surgery) of the recent films, and it's really stupid and what? ... B-grade schmaltz even ... ? I don't hold much hope for him.
Not really sure how you could not atleast like Bin-jip (3-Iron) or Samaria (Samaritan Girl). They are both excellent films.
This guy sucks ass for the most part. He caters to the unknowing Western audience's "orientalist" fetish. He has virtually zero following in Korea, not even among those who appreciate art films. But he is very clever at manipulating and duping the Western audience into thinking that his films are somehow profound. And he does have an exquisite painter's eye. His "Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter... and Spring" is one fraud of a film. It is a complete and shameless ripoff of the vastly superior Korean film "Why Has the Bodhi Dharma Left for the East?" I will say that he is a first-rate provocateur. But he is most definitely not a first-rate filmmaker. He has made a couple of good films though, which in my opinion are "Bad Guy" and "The Isle."