Paul Bäumer, a young German schoolboy, along with his friends, is inspired by his schoolmaster to “save the Fatherland” and joins the Kaiser’s forces. Their illusions are soon dispelled, however, by the cruel realities of battle, relieved only by a brief romantic interlude with some French farm girls and the humorous interjections of Katz and Tjaden. When Paul, the only survivor of the group, returns home, he finds the professor still haranguing his young scholars to join the conflict; and when Paul denounces this attitude, he is proclaimed a coward by the youths. Tiring of the false impression of war at home, he returns to the front to instruct his new comrades in warfare. As the sole survivor of this group also, Paul reaches over the top of a trench to catch a butterfly and is killed by an enemy sniper. … Quiet reigns on the front lines. –AFI
Lewis Milestone (born Lewis Milstein in the Ukraine) came to the U.S. as a teenager, and while in the Army during World War I was an assistant director on training films. In Hollywood, he began working as an editor, and after writing and assistant directing in the early 1920s, he helmed his first feature for producer Howard Hughes, Seven Sinners (1925). Milestone’s comedy Two Arabian Knights (1927) was widely admired, but the director didn’t hit his stride until 1930 with All Quiet on the Western Front, his landmark adaptation of Erich Maria Remarque’s war novel. In the ‘30s Milestone scored major achievements in several genres, including comedy (The Front Page), musical (Hallelujah, I’m a Bum), and espionage (The General Died at Dawn); he capped the decade with his classic drama Of Mice And Men (1939), adaptated from John Steinbeck’s novella. Notable among his work of the 1940s and ‘50s are the war films Edge of Darkness (1943), The Purple Heart (1944), A Walk in the Sun (1946), and… read more
A very good, if long adaptation of All Quiet. Unfortunately, it feels incredibly dated, especially in dialogue. What sounded true and realistic in Remarque's novel feels cliché and wrong in the film. The innovative battle scenes, however, make up for any dramatic shortcomings. They're extraordinary.
The battle scenes are so technically innovative and thrilling I had a hard time believing this film was made in 1930. They just pulse with so much cinematic energy. However a good chunk of the film feels stilted, stagy, and dated, and it's a shame because there are some truly powerful scenes contained here. However it's an important film, and along with M the first great sound film.
Raymond Griffith, silent comedian, has fallen into such neglect as to be virtually erased from screen history, it seems. None of his comedy
For Germans, it must have indeed been a strange experience watching Lewis Milestone’s All Quiet on the Western Front. Still crippled by the aftermath of WWI and with a new chancellor rising in power… read review
I really don’t understand all the negative comments, while the acting performances might been seen as over-the-top, imagine how you yourself would act if in their situations. I found the camerawork… read review