Expected something nice, received something really great. Clever and quick, parts of it initially seem meandering or meaningless but a lot more than meets the eye. Great use of music, some inspired acting, really nice.
I love when youtube has these full movies.. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFFFOfxNG04
Having previously enjoyed Menzel’s I Served the King of England, this - his breakthrough work and arguably still his most loved - came as a disappointment. Marginally charming at best and largely aimless and rambling in its storytelling, or so it just felt to me.
In 1967, Time called CWT "a series of contradictions: a tragic comedy, a peaceful war movie, a success story of a failure" - all fitting descriptions of this coming-of-age tale of the descendent of a long line of eccentrics. The mid-section was droll, and I didn't care for the comedic flourishes provided by the incidental music, but there is a sweetness about the film's charming characters and crisp cinematography.
There's a sense of purity, more than simple innocence on its character's behaviour related to sex, work, responsabilities, hard to find in other coming-of-age films. The ending has that rupture needed for any piece of art to avoid being geometrical. A step that filmmakers usually refuse to take.
CLOSELY WATCHED TRAINS is the perfect example of a smart comedy. A tragic period, WWII, a naive hero à la Jerry Lewis, sex scenes handled lightly and without any vulgarity like the ink pads over the young woman's leg which is one of the most erotic scenes I've seen in a movie of the 60's, a lot of great supporting roles and an ending that leaves the audience speechless . 93 minutes of sheer pleasure. Masterpiece.
Closely Watched Trains (1966) DIR Jirí Menzel This one, particularly the ending, didn’t work for me. Coming-of-age movies recommended: Loves of a Blonde Director: Milos Forman Flirting (1991) Director:John Duigan -Thandie Newton's first film role- Nicole Kidman's last Australian film The Last Picture Show Y Tu Mama Tambien
Wonderful, thick, morbid quirkiness before quirky was necessary to sell a script.