Welcome to MUBI.
Your online cinema. Anytime, anywhere.

Reviews of Mother

Displaying all 4 reviews

back to Mother

Picture of Amir Syarif Siregar

Amir Syarif Siregar

1May10

Tahun 2009 mungkin dapat dikatakan sebagai salah satu tahun yang paling membanggakan bagi industri film Korea Selatan. Bagaimana tidak, dua film mereka, yang sama-sama bergenre thriller, mendapat rekognisi luas dan pujian dari banyak kritikus film dunia. Thirst, sebuah thriller dengan tema vampire yang sedang populer, banyak digambarkan sebagai jawaban yang jauh lebih baik dari Korea Selatan atas Twilight. Sementara Mother, berhasil menjadi film unggulan Korea Selatan untuk bersaing di kategori Best Foreign Language di ajang The 82nd Academy Awards yang lalu, walaupun akhirnya harus gagal di tahap penyeleksian akhir.

Mother sendiri disutradarai oleh Bong Joon-ho, sutradara yang telah familiar dengan berbagai ajang penghargaan setelah karyanya, The Host (2006), juga bernasib sama, memperoleh banyak pujian dan penghargaan dari berbagai kritikus film dunia.

Film ini sendiri mengisahkan mengenai Hye-ja (Kim Hye-ja), seorang wanita petani ginseng dengan kemampuan akupuntur yang telah hidup menjanda sekian tahun. Hidupnya saat ini hanya ditemani oleh seorang puteranya, Do-joon (Won Bin), yang walau telah berusia 28 tahun, namun masih sering tidur di ranjang yang sama dengan dirinya. Bukan apa-apa, jika dibandingkan dengan pria dewasa lainnya, Do-joon memiliki sedikit keterbelakangan emosional dalam kesehariannya.

Walau begitu, Do-joon menjalani hari-harinya bagaikan orang biasa. Walau tidak disetujui oleh ibunya, ia sering sekali berkumpul bersama Jin-tae (Jin Goo), pria pengangguran yang menjadi sahabat baik Do-joon. Bersama, mereka sering mengunjungi bar, mabuk-mabukan atau melakukan berbagai kegiatan tidak berguna lainnya. Masalah datang di satu malam, ketika Do-joon dan Jin-tae berjanji untuk bertemu di satu bar, namun hingga dini hari menjelang, Jin-tae belum menunjukkan batang hidungnya. Akhirnya, dengan keadaan mabuk, Do-joon pun diusir oleh sang pemilik bar.

Dalam perjalanan pulangnya, Do-joon kemudian membuntuti seorang gadis yang terlihat ketakutan. Sempat menggoda sang gadis beberapa saat, namun berakhir dengan penolakan, Do-joon akhirnya memilih untuk pulang ke rumahnya. Keesokan harinya, ternyata sang gadis telah ditemukan tewas pada sebuah rumah yang tadi malam dilewati Do-joon bersama sang gadis. Sialnya, beberapa barang bukti yang ditemukan di TKP, menunjukkan bahwa Do-joon adalah sang pelaku pembunuhan gadis tersebut. Dengan menggunakan teknik-teknik tertentu, pihak kepolisian akhirnya berhasil membuat Do-joon menandatangani surat pengakuan bahwa dialah yang membunuh sang gadis.

Tak terima putera satu-satunya diperlakukan semena-mena, Hye-ja akhirnya menempuh segala cara untuk membebaskan Do-joon. Cara seperti menghubungi beberapa pengacara terkenal di daerahnya, hingga mengumpulkan sendiri berbagai barang bukti untuk menunjukkan bahwa sanga anak tidak bersalah, dilakukan oleh Hye-ja. Perlahan-lahan, Hye-ja akhirnya berhasil menemukan jejak sang pembunuh sang gadis yang sebenarnya.

Memadukan drama keluarga, thriller dan sedikit komedi, Bong Joon-ho berhasil menghidupkan naskah cerita yang ia tulis bersama Park Eun-kyo ini. Walau pada beberapa adegan, khususnya pada beberapa adegan menjelang akhir film, terasa sedikit diperpanjang, namun tetap saja tidak membuat Mother kehilangan daya tariknya. Tentu saja, hal ini tidak lepas dari daya tarik dua pemeran utamanya, Kim Hye-ja dan Won Bin.

Lihat saja dari adegan pertama film ini — yang ternyata merupakan salah satu adegan akhir dari film ini yang diletakkan di awal film — yang menunjukkan Hye-ja menari di tengah-tengah rerumputan. Terlihat aneh pada awalnya, namun dengan ekspresi wajah yang sendu, adegan tersebut merupakan salah satu adegan paling menyentuh di film itu. Adegan tersebut juga menjadi penanda bagi setiap penontonnya bahwa mereka akan menyimak akting yang sangat hebat dari aktris senior Korea Selatan, Kim Hye-ja, yang menampilkan tingkatan akting yang sangat memukau, terutama dari setiap ekspresi wajah yang ia keluarkan di sepanjang film.

Aktor muda, Won Bin, juga ternyata mampu menandingi penampilan kaliber Kim Hye-ja dengan memberikan gambaran yang lugu akan karakter Do-joon. Walau memiliki screen-time yang lebih sedikit daripada Kim-Hye ja, namun tetap saja, setiap Won Bin tampil sebagai Do-joon, Mother mampu menjadi terasa lebih mengena dan berwarna. Penampilan kedua pemeran utama ini juga diperkuat lagi oleh beberapa pemeran pendukung, khususnya oleh Jin Goo yang berperan sebagai Jin-tae, yang memiliki karakter sedikit sulit untuk ditebak di sepanjang film ini berjalan.

Dengan naskah cerita yang menarik — plus sedikit twist di akhir jalan cerita –, eksekusi yang tepat dari para pemerannya dan beberapa potong sinematografi yang cukup indah, menjadikan Mother sebuah film yang mampu membuat penontonnya terus menyimak kisah Do-joon dan ibunya dalam memecahkan permasalahan yang ditawarkan di jalan cerita film ini. Sederhana, namun mampu mengikat dengan sempurna.

Rating: 4 / 5

  • Currently 4.0/5 Stars.
Picture of jaredmobarak

jaredmo​barak

11Apr10

The poster for Joon-ho Bong’s newest work Madeo [Mother], along with the one word title, screams thriller where the mother at hand will do anything for her child. Bin Won’s Yoon Do-joon appears wide-eyed and scared, hiding himself behind Hye-ja Kim, a woman with steely determination to protect him. So, when the film begins with an odd sequence of Kim wandering aimlessly through a field of tall grass, eventually breaking out into an interpretative dance to the music superimposed over the imagery, I couldn’t help but get drawn in, wondering how this impromptu moment deals with the mystery to come. The story itself deals with the railroading of Yoon for a murder no one really believes he is capable of and his mother’s search to find the real killer once the police close the case without any certainty. She will stop at nothing to clear his name, whether it be turning against those she trusts or entrenching herself deeper into the secrets no one bothered to look for after her son’s arrest. Every mother would stand behind her son; the exercise here is to see just how far Kim’s character is willing to go.

After the dance, we are suddenly thrust into the city streets where Kim is cutting vegetables at the store she works for and Yoon is across the street playing with a dog and his friend Jin-Tae, (Ku Jin). Without warning, a BMW comes whipping through, hitting the boy and driving off. Kim is distraught and runs out to see how her son is doing when Jin-Tae drives up to go after the hit-and-runners, knowing a car that expensive can only be going to the country club. This is where all the trouble starts—it’s the boy’s first run in with the law and also the event where Yoon collects his golf balls and Jin-Tae steals his driver—as well as the point we discover there is something not quite right with Yoon. His mother is a peculiar woman who practices acupuncture without a license and deals in medication for fertility amongst other things, supposedly taking some to get pregnant with her son. The mixture of that and the fact she gives him some kind of medicine each day—not to mention a past incident with insecticide that will be revealed later on—begs the question whether she is the reason her son is simple. Don’t call him a retard because he’ll go after you, just like mother taught him; there are definitely a few missed connections in his brain.

Bin Won does a fantastic job portraying the simpleton, unable to focus for very long on one task, often forgetting details of his life, and never thinking before acting. Mother always said that if someone calls him a name he should kick their butt and if they hit him he should hit them back twice. The boy doesn’t know any better and therefore follows all directions to the letter; it’s how he was trained. Behind it all, though, is a kind-hearted soul, unable to willing hurt a waterbug, but also without the means to realize the consequence of his actions. Hye-ja Kim’s mother dotes on him due to this fact, constantly at his side to make sure he doesn’t get in trouble—the two even sleep in the same bed at night despite him being 28 years old. Her performance is at the center of it all, turning from the concerned parent to the vigilant amateur detective looking for the clues to clear her son’s name. The unfortunate facts against him are that people saw him follow the deceased girl to the place she died and one of the golf balls, he so neatly signed his name to, was found by the body. Besides his cries of innocence and everyone’s knowledge of his affliction, you can’t blame the police for putting him away and moving on.

Admittedly, watching her look for clues and try her best to get an expensive lawyer and appeal to the police chief’s kindness is a bit longwinded. The amount of time spent started to make me feel that perhaps that was all there was to the film; maybe there would be no revelation or surprising incident to shock me as I so hoped. I began to feel disappointed, even when clues about the victim started to be revealed, showing that she wasn’t quite the innocent little poor girl people assumed. But then the story starts to speed up, Jin-tae comes back to play cop—effectively I might add—and motives are uncovered to make almost every single male in town a suspect in the murder. Kim’s character finally has something to hold onto with substance, rather than trespassing on property to steal things she believes are evidence. The pieces begin to fall into place, illegal and abusive interrogations are performed, Yoon begins to remember things, and it soon falls to the boy’s mother to confront who everyone thinks is the real killer. It’s a scene that makes the film—effective in that it validates all the missed clues and mistaken assumptions before it, but also risks proving it all a cheat, spinning things in a way to create a fantastic ending that only masks an ineffective whole a la The Usual Suspects.

Saying that Madeo is nothing more than its end is a bit harsh and unwarranted. Joon-ho Bong has created a beautiful piece of cinema with some very memorable scenes including that strange dance in the grass and a gorgeous final shot of people gyrating on a bus in silhouette while the sun blinds us through the open spaces. He also infuses a few things that beg to be viewed again, symbolism that I am not familiar with, but could add another layer to what’s happening. Both Yoon and the dead girl Moon Ah-jung, played by Mun-hee Na, in flashback cover their right eye when talking. Does this allude to a representation of Horus and his ‘all seeing eye’ in Egyptian culture? And what about the fixation on feet getting dirty? We see Kim try and spread her son’s urine on the sidewalk with her foot, there is her sliding in wet mud, and close-ups of her socked feet sneaking out of Jin-tae’s apartment. What makes these moments so intriguing is that the film works coherently without them. Their simple existence makes me believe more is going on than seen on the surface. It makes me want to view it again and do a little research, adding one more level to a film that otherwise appears very straight-forward with only a tricky ending to set it apart from other thrillers being released these days.

Madeo [Mother] 7/10

http://jaredmobarakreviews.wordpress.com/2010/04/11/madeo-mother/

  • Currently 3.0/5 Stars.

Andhika Eka Buana

12Nov09

if i am an academy voter,i will try my best to make MOTHER become one of the nominee of 2010 oscar for best foreign film. that statement just tells just how brilliant this movie is. This is comes as no surprise,as it comes from Boong Joon-ho (alongside Park Chan-wook and Kim Jee-won,the three lions of korea).

from the tone of the film,it is not much differrnt than his Memories of Murder.But if when i watching MoM the feeling is just like watching a Fincher’s movie,well,in Mother,it is just refreshing.only by reading the premise,i know i’m into something entirely different.A mother trying to solve a murder mystery to help his son getting away from jail?i’m in.

The highlight of Mother is,of course,the titular character herself,played mesmerizingly good by Kim Hye-ja (i also wanna take my money on her for best actress of 2010,by a long shot). Her elegant dancing in the beginning and ending of the film through some beautiful tango-ish music, is just enough to convince me to adore her character,no matter what act she did in the movie.and adding the unpredictable nature of the story itself just making this movie more and more incredible

  • Currently 5.0/5 Stars.
Picture of Teddy Cheong

Teddy Cheong

5Sep09

I will preface this by stating that Mother takes nurturing to a whole new level. This goes beyond simple breastfeeding and cooing. In fact, one particular scene even bordered along taboo lines. However, I also found this extreme relationship to be the most rewarding aspect of the film (which was in large part made plausible by Kim Hye-ja’s performance). The thriller side of it all is actually pretty standard and even a tad underwhelming considering Bong directed Memories of Murder years back. Despite a mixed bag, this is still one of the more interesting films to have come out of South Korea this year.

  • Currently 3.0/5 Stars.