Wall

monkeyninja

10Nov11

A bit of a disappointment after "Paris Je t'aime". There were a few good moments, but it didn't feel romantic like its predecessor or to be about its host city.

nowhere_fast likes this

Tisa

3Oct11

I did like Shia's segment. That one was quite haunting.

ULA ZUHRA likes this

Tisa

3Oct11

Few hits; lots of miss.

Tyler Aikens

27Oct11

Agreed

Best Segment:Joshua Marston Segments I Liked:Jiang Yao,Shunji Iwai,Brett Ratner,Fatih Akin. Segments I Didn't Like:Mira Nair,Yvan Attal,Shekhar Kapur,Natalie Portman,Randy Ballsmeyer. Worst Segment:Allen Hughes

ALICE X

31Aug11

Where is New York?

Julia

28Aug11

I would have loved this 10x more if the chose 3 scenes and released them as short films. All and all I thought it was 'cute'.

FailedImitator

14Jun11

Apparently, black people don't love New York. That, or there's no one to tell their story. Where's Spike Lee when you need the man?

Echydo

27May11

Very little of New York is shown in this movie. A more reflective title could be "Variations on Love in a City That Just Happens to Be Called New York" (...à la Hong Sang Soo)

mixn and Amani like this

Gabriel Argüello

2May11

A bit less kitsch than "Paris je t'aime" in general but a waste of time, it's a bad movie overall.

Malik

10Apr11

New York is bigger than Manhattan and for more diverse than this film gave time for.

Kyle Lewis likes this

Eleni Ashton

8Feb11

Painful.

Amani

26Nov10

I think it could have been a much better movie. From what I've seen of Paris, je t'aime , I believe that was a better film, and this one could have been on the same level. However, the acting along with the stories had fabulous direction. I don't deny that point. It's just they could have highlighted the boroughs/ neighborhoods in a more elaborate way I felt as if the city wasn't a character.

Jye Sherwell

13Oct10

What a huge improvement over "Paris, I love you".

Billy Clare

29Sep10

I found this to bequite terrible! Very big let down after Paris Je T'aime! Booo.

Caden Cotard

18Sep10

A brilliant, Altmanesque view of NYC. Far superior to Paris, Je T'aime.

yoy

13Sep10

well i haven't watched Paris Je T'aime, but i loved the idea to put some stories about different unique specific people in the city. But I think it would be a greater movie if the movies are connected by one single character, like the one who brings up the videocamera.. but she really take some stories in her shoots. well i don't really know... hmmm.. btw i just like the one which is written by Minghella. :)

Abby.

19Aug10

Not nearly as good as Paris Je T'aime

Dan.

17Aug10

paris je t'aime was much more romanticized... but what else would u expect in the city of love. new york i love you wasnt about romance per se... but of random chance encounters... just like how that one line goes in the movie 'you never know who your gonna meet, etc...' people should stop trying to compare the two movies and see new york i love you for what it is. Its fun, clever, and has that short story magic

Elvia Francis

12Aug10

"Paris Je T'aime" was magnificent, however this was a would-be mirror image of "Paris Je T'aime" that failed immensely. It's mostly depressing than lovely!

Ardhi Syaifuddin

28Jul10

It's more "Manhattan, I Love You" rather than "New York, I Love You". Where's Spike Lee when you need him?

Malik likes this

william

6Jun10

very boring thats it, nothing compare to paris, j'taime

william

6Jun10

very boring thats it, nothing compare to paris, j'taime

Ademption

24May10

New York, I wank you.

FailedImitator

11May10

Meh. I think I like one, two stories tops. Paris was so much better.

rko281

10May10

The Ratner short is absolutely the worst thing about this, Igor. By a long shot, too. Iwai, Akin and Marston had the best three for me. But apart from taking place in NYC, I didn't feel like any of them were particularly New York stories aside from Marston's.