DT
27Nov11
“Communism existed once, during two 45 minute half-times, when Honved, from Budapest, won over England by 6-3. The English played individually, and the Hungarians, collectively.” Brilliant.
After a rolling montage of war and devastation, and with the burnt ruins of Sarajevo still standing as a solitary witness to the last great horror of the 20th century, Godard asks the question: "how can we live?" The audience responds: "with our fingers in our ears and our eyes tightly closed." Heaven really is a place where nothing ever happens.
it's funny how words betray the film. they do not lie, but they betray it. films like inglorious basterds or munchen betray levinas, but differently. in spite of sophisticated choices of texts and additional music,i found this film spiritless. if tolerance accepts two types of opposing certitudes, then how can it still define war as good vs. evil, since it is the clash of such equal systems of certitudes that war is?
By far the most cogent of Godard’s video essays that I’ve seen. While I enjoyed the likes of In Praise of Love and Film Socialisme on a (strictly) artistic level, this is the only one that’s actually engaged me on an emotional one. A fascinating, diverse slice of Godardalia.
Less quotes of wonder and awe would make for a better trailer which actually shows what the film is about.
A voyage inside Godard´s mind: first, wake you up with his vision of hell ( = Sartre´s vision?), after in purgatory he uses dialogues and memorables images to create a brainstorm in our minds and finnaly we ´re are transported to his heaven, to consider about his cinematographic work. Trip that i would love to do everyday! Great movie, indeed.
The world is now split in two , between tose who line up to voice their misery and those for whom this public display provides a daily of moral confort to their domination .
One of Godard's best. Too many people talk about the man as if he was dead but with films like this and In Praise of Love ... he is all too alive ... all too talented.
"There's more inspiration and humanity in defeat than in victory..."
how I was introduced to the Godardian world ? watching Notre Music. I have a pre - Godard and a post - Godard era ...