I'm a big Woody fan, but I'm also very critical of his films. I though this was great.
As much as i respect Woody Allen, I just cannot enjoy this film. Bland is the best description for September, I think Woody Allen struggled with this film, He reshot the film with a whole new cast. The conecpt of staying in one house and replicating a stage play is good but it was not executed very well. Still with the fequent pace Woody made his films its understandable to make a mistake every once in a while.