Reviews of Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
Displaying all 9 reviews
ivanatman
10Jan11
Karena terlalu sering menonton drama, saya hampir lupa bagaimana cara menikmati film Sci-Fi yang penuh adegan brutal dengan efek visual sepanjang cerita. Saya seringkali berganti-ganti posisi duduk, salah tingkah, bingung dan was-was kalau-kalau film ini ternyata buruk dan “Ya Tuhan, apakah saya akan membuang-buang waktu selama dua setengah jam di sini?” Untung saya nonton sendirian.
Tapi bioskop itu selalu penuh sampai deretan bangku paling bawah dan tiketnya bahkan sudah habis empat jam sebelum tayang. Tandanya animo masyarakat begitu tinggi dan saya akhirnya mengantri demi menonton Transformers: Revenge of The Fallen (2009). Saya sudah memasang ekspektasi yang rendah walaupun ada nama Steven Spielberg dan Michael Bay di dalamnya, serta Megan Fox yang mungkin diekspos secara maksimal untuk keperluan visual semata, yang membuat penonton laki-laki menjadi scopophilis semua.
Ada yang tidak tahu Transformers? Generasi 1980an mungkin sudah akrab dengan serial kartun berjudul The Transformers yang dulu pernah ditayangkan di televisi lokal. Mereka adalah kaum robot yang berasal dari planet Cybertron, yang kemudian terpecah menjadi dua kubu: Autobots yang dipimpin oleh Optimus Prime (protagonis) dan Decepticons yang dipimpin oleh Megatron (antagonis). Para robot tersebut bisa bertransformasi menjadi berbagai bentuk kendaraan, perkakas, dan binatang. Mereka hidup berdampingan dengan manusia dengan ukuran yang elastis, bisa mengecil dan membesar. Semuanya mendapatkan energi dari sebuah ‘kunci’ yang disebut dengan Matrix of Leadership (ah, bagi yang tidak tahu apa-apa tentang Transformers, tidak usah pusing, karena masih banyak hal lain yang perlu dipikirkan).
Kembali pada prequel-nya Transformers, Megatron yang sekarat ternyata tidak mati. Ia kembali mengumpulkan energi dan menghimpun pasukan dari luar angkasa atas perintah The Fallen. Pada saat yang tepat, ia meluncur ke Bumi dan berhasil menamatkan riwayat sang Optimus Prime yang selama ini melindungi planet dari serangan Decepticons. Sedangkan Sam Witwicky (Shia LeBeouf) dan Mikaela Banes (Megan Fox) berada di tengah-tengah pertarungan kedua kubu tersebut dengan misi menghidupkan kembali Optimus Prime untuk pertarungan final melawan Megatron dan pasukannya.
Yang terjadi kemudian adalah suara dentingan besi, ledakan besar, tabrakan keras dan deru peluru non-stop yang mendominasi, bagaikan orgasme tanpa henti. Semuanya diciptakan dengan efek visual CGI yang ‘mengerikan’ dengan kamera beresolusi tinggi. Robot-robot dalam Transformers membuat Power Rangers, Ultraman, Cyborg, Robocop, atau Terminators seperti karikatur kasar coretan anak SD.
Walaupun penuh adegan kekerasan dan beberapa adegan hot, Transformers pada dasarnya adalah film anak-anak dengan rating PG-13. Namun, jangan mengharapkan dialog-dialog hebat atau akting memukau dalam film seperti ini. Itu sudah pasti. Situs RottenTomatoes hanya memberikan rating 21% dan menyebut Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen sebagai film yang “noisy, underplotted, and overlong special effects extravaganza that lacks a human touch.” Subplot-nya tidak pernah dikembangkan dan sangat mudah ditebak; mungkin dibuat untuk mengisi kekosongan beberapa menit ketika para robot sedang bersiap-siap untuk bertempur. Film ini seakan mengkhianati intelegensi.
Tetapi Michael Bay tentu saja tidak mau berjudi dengan menampilkan adegan-adegan sentimentil ‘tidak penting’ dalam film ini. Di tengah kemelut robot-robot penuh nafsu tersebut, adegan manusiawi apapun yang ditampilkan akan sia-sia saja. Toh, penonton tetap tertawa-tawa walaupun leluconnya garing dan slapstick khas komedi toilet. Lalu terharu menyaksikan ending yang klise-nya minta ampun. Pesan-pesan moralnya yang kadang dipaksakan dalam cerita tetap membuat orang-orang mengangguk-angguk takzim tanda setuju. Dan di bioskop itu saya melihat sekelompok anak-anak bertepuk tangan ketika Optimus Prime kembali hidup!
Sebagian orang mungkin perlu menyiapkan aspirin dan obat tetes mata untuk menonton film ini, lalu keluar dari gedung bioskop sambil memaki-maki. Tapi menurut saya, Transformers: Revenge of The Fallen dan film lain ber-genre sama memang murni ditonton untuk ditertawakan dan bukan untuk ditanggapi secara serius. Seperti halnya junk food, franchise Transformers memang populer, tapi bulan depan ia pasti akan terlupakan.
- Currently 1.0/5 Stars.
Marcus WP
23Dec10
im well aware that transformers is about giant alien robots, transforming into vehicles, doing battles against each other on planet earth. So from the start im not expecting this movie to carry the same depth as a film by Tarkofsky or Ingmar Bergman. But after watching the dissapointing sequel, i think a slow, “artsy”, black & white version of Transformers 2 wouldve be a lot more interesting than whats playing in theaters right now. Ive never been a fan of Michael Bey, and this movie legitimzes my hatred for that guy. The dialouge sounded like stuff a 7 year old would say while playing with action figures. Aside from the shitty writing, there were WAY too many uneccessary slow-motion shots of Megan Fox. Dont get me wrong, she IS very attractive, but it almost got to the point where 2 transformers would be in the middle of smashing a city to pieces, and than all of a sudden theres a random slow-motion shot of Megan Fox bending over to pick something up. If i wanted to see that, i couldve just stayed home, and prowled the internet for REAL porn. Now…the most upsettnig part of the Transformers sequel is the addition of the 2 new “ethnic” autobots, equip with gold teeth and fluent ebonics. Even in robot form, black people get no respect. So yeah, this movie is nothing new. Typical Michael Bey, slow-mo explotion shots with people randomlly yelling “NOOOO!” or “LOOK OOOUUUT!” every 10 minutes.
- Currently 1.0/5 Stars.
Amir Syarif Siregar
21Apr10
Berhasil melawan semua anggapan bahwa film live action pertama Transformers pada tahun 2007 lalu akan gagal, film tersebut malah berhasil memuncaki tangga box office sekaligus mengumpulkan perolehan US$708,2 juta hingga saat ini. Tidak heran, sutradara Michael Bay langsung mengumpulkan tim kembali untuk menyiapkan sebuah sekuel.
Di Revenge of the Fallen, Sam Witwicky (LaBeouf) dikisahkan akan beranjak memasuki dunia kuliah di luar kota,yang berarti ia harus meninggalkan kedua orangtuanya (Dunn-Taylor) serta kekasihnya, Mikaela Banes (Fox). Sam tentunya tidak akan menyangka ketika Optimus Prime memintanya kembali bergabung bersama Autobots setelah tim Autobots mengetahui bahwa Decepticons mulai membentuk kekuatan kembali untuk mengambil alih kekuasaan di muka Bumi.
Bagi fanboy dan penggemar film-film action popcorn lainnya tentu tidak akan merasa menyesal dan bahkan akan kagum dengan kekuatan special effect yang ditawarkan Bay lewat Revenge of the Fallen. Namun, harus diakui pula, kekuatan film ini terhenti hanya pada kekuatan special effect itu tadi.
Pertama, dengan durasi hampir mencapai 150 menit, Bay tidak melengkapi film ini dengan naskah yang kuat. Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen dipenuhi oleh berbagai adegan yang dirasakan tidak perlu, dipanjang-panjangkan serta dialog-dialog yang terkesan bodoh. Bahkan bila diucapkan oleh sebuah robot sekalipun. Hasilnya, hampir setengah dari isi film ini adalah berbagai action berupa pertarungan ataupun ledakan yang dengan dosisi yang (sedikit) berlebihan tadi, akan membuat beberapa penonton mulai jenuh dan kelelahan.
Kalau ingin dibandingkan dengan film pertama, Revenge of the Fallen sepertinya lebih ingin mengeksplor lebih dalam mengenai kehidupan para robot daripada kehidupan para tokoh manusianya. Mungkin karena itu juga film ini malah menjadi terkesan kurang sentuhan manusia. Bahkan untuk tokoh utama seperti Sam dan Mikaela, yang jatah penampilan mereka harus rela diambil Megatron, The Fallen, maupun Optimus Prime, ditambah dengan adanya penambahan beberapa tokoh robot, yang akan semakin menyulikan penonton untuk menikmati cerita film ini.
Dari sisi cast, tidak ada yang benar-benar menonjol di film ini. Seperti yang dituliskan diatas, kehadiran para robot, yang telah mulai bnayak bicara tersebut, menyebabkan kehadiran tokoh manusia sedikit terkurangi. Oh, Bay sepertinya harus memperbaiki beberapa penokohan yang diberikan di film ini. Hal ini dikarenakan beberapa tokoh film ini digambarkan demikian bodohnya, dengan berbagai joke yang sepertinya dipaksakan untuk lucu.
Kalau Anda benar-benar berniat menonton film ini tanpa harus memikirkan berbagai aspek film lainnya, ditambah lagi jika Anda merupakan seorang penggemar film-film action, maka film ini pastilah akan menjadi film utama pilihan Anda. Durasi lebih dari 2 jam yang ditawarkan oleh Michael Bay lewat Revenge of the Fallen hanyalah berisi berbagai action para robot dengan efek suara yang menggelegar dan diselingi dengan adegan dan dialog bodoh dari para karakter manusianya.
Maaf. Mengecewakan.
Rating : 2 / 5
- Currently 2.0/5 Stars.
Fadli Rizal
2Mar10
If you take Transformers with a grain of salt…you’ll have a pretty fun time checking out both the robotic (transformers) and human (Megan Fox) eye candy Morphs from Army-enlisting ad to toy ad (on its way passing through a panoply of car ads, computer ads, beer ads) without ever becoming a movie Thank god the Transformers speak primarily in proper nouns—if they hadn’t shouted “Optimus! Megatron!” every time they struck a blow, I’d have no idea what was happening. indonesia java international destination
Jye Sherwell
6Oct09
So it turns out that all the transformers now love to crack one-liners in nearly every scene. Horrible over the top direction from Michael Bay, cliches throughout and few moments where I actually enjoyed myself. Those few moments were when the film actually slowed down enough for Shia LaBeouf to get a few hilarious & quickly spoken words out before the next boring action sequence came along. This is nothing but one big & overlong pile of crap!
- Currently 1.0/5 Stars.
mofo
16Sep09
the one redeeming factor of this movie is seeing megan fox run braless in slow motion but the rest of the movie should just go away. they should have just extended that one shot to the entire 3 nd a half hours or whatever the f word it was. also how does this movie have 12 fans on here?!?!?!? those people should all have their accounts deleted. why are you even here if you’re into this trash? just go away and watch high school musical or something.
- Currently 1.0/5 Stars.
moonmaster9000
26Jul09
Lets get one thing straight: Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen isn’t a film. It isn’t even entertainment. It’s a two and half hour commercial for General Motors and the US military. It has all the depth of a trailer, and all the plot of a porno. It’s a series of loud, predictable fight scenes strung together with sex-ploitative shots of Meagan Fox, knocks on Obama and diplomacy, and arguably racist characterizations (the two “black” transformers – complete with gold teeth – are little more than illiterate, violent, and buffoonish minstrel stock characters). It is, hands down, some of the laziest, most manipulative film-making I’ve ever seen. It had so many continuity errors that my wife and I caught at least five in a first viewing. Sitting through this abomination was one of the most serious tests of my patience in quite some time.
Revenge resembles a trailer to such a striking degree that at first I didn’t even realize that the film had started. It opens with a prehistoric hunting party approaching a spaceship that has just landed in their territory. A Don LaFontaine-esque voiceover explains the images with cliches like “the dawn of man” and “worlds collide” while Transformers emerge from the ship and proceed to destroy all of the humans. We then skip to the present: 11:24PM, Shanghai, China (where it’s still light outside somehow). The US Military and several transformers hunt down one of the few remaining Decepticons, causing all kinds of havoc in the city and forcing a massive media cover-up. Afterwords, during the debriefing, a special presidential envoy, suspicious of the transformers, challenges Optimus Prime (the most powerful of the transformers) and threatens to pull the plug on the whole team. Later on in the film, that same envoy will attempt to appease invading Decepticons while referring to it as “diplomacy.” Wow, it’s exactly what John McCain said Obama would do!
Shia LeBouf reprises his “role” as Sam Witicky, the great grandson of explorer Archibald Witicky who had unwittingly re-activated the frozen Megatron during an exploratory expedition into the Arctic circle. Conveniently, we again find Sam possessing another map that the Decepticons need (seriously, did this film even have writers, or did they just substitute names and locations from the last script and give it a new title?). A chip from the All Spark, the energy source destroyed in the first film, causes Sam to have visions of symbols, which we eventually learn from an aging rogue Decepticon are clues to the location of the “Matrix of Leadership” (no, I’m not making this up). Sam and his girlfriend Mikaela Banes (Megan Fox, who I’ve been promised is NOT a porn star) are in race against my patience to find the Matrix before the Decepticons can use it to the destroy the Sun.
A pubescent horn-ball and his unfortunate girlfriend sat at the end of our row. In between slurps of his girlfriend’s saliva, he would loudly proclaim his approval for the film with insightful one-liners like “Why he talk like that?”, “Shit! He ripped his fuckin’ ass out!” or my personal favorite, “Damn, you see those robot’s balls? HA HA!!!” Normally I would have been annoyed by interruptions like these, but I eventually came to appreciate these quips. I realized that this is exactly the emotional and intellectual level that Transformers caters to. I was, however, slightly disturbed by the large number of adults in the crowd apparently deriving the same mindless pleasure from the film that our socially-engineered homunculus enjoyed. And since a film like this leaves no room for narrative invention, I had plenty of time to ponder the fate of a society that continually rewards our entertainment industry for vomiting such bilious tripe.
Final Thought: If you enjoy explosions, PG-13 sexual situations, and shiny objects, you’ll love Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen.
- Currently 1.0/5 Stars.
Aaron Dumont
26Jun09
Colors bleed, flash, and pulsate through and through each other, dwarfing the movie’s characters into models to direct one through a relentless mesh of flashing lights and visual noise. The movie, though, does at times incorporate myth and politics, but it’s all consistently drowned out by the endless flood of explosions and aimless idiocy. The images, platform and idea here is rooted in hyperactive testosterone. Revenge of the Fallen suggests a world, a government, even a social system of droning, thoughtless sound and fury, a vision of anything held as art and intellect as laughable theatrical props in a wet-dream toy commercial of sorts—-it seems Michael Bay cannot find a way to just…stop. This isn’t a movie in a coherent or narrative form. It’s a series of repulsive flares of immaturity sent recklessly careening in all sorts of different directions, but all flying away from the grounds of anything humble, intelligent, recognizable, or even respectable. There are movies that scream all they want for a revolution, sure. This movie however, screams for evolution.
And no, I won’t turn my brain off, you mindless fucking zombies.
- Currently 1.0/5 Stars.
jaredmobarak
24Jun09
My screening of Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen ended around 10:00pm. What do we see in the lobby as we exit the theatre? That’s right, a line already forming for the midnight show, less than two hours away, the premiere timeslot to expose the world to the ancient Decepticon Fallen. Those kids were ready for a good time, hoping that the sequel lived up to the surprisingly effective first installment. If any of them had asked me as I walked by what I thought, I would have told them the truth … it’s not that bad. In hindsight, I think I gave the original too high a rating with an 8/10. It did entertain and the computer graphics were impeccable, but too often did it have me shaking my head at the clumsy script and abundance of cheese. It was a crapshoot on what to expect with a sequel from maestro of destruction Michael Bay. All I knew for sure was that he’d bring more robots, more explosions, and more carnage, because, frankly, that’s how he rolls.
Let’s put this phenomenon in perspective here. Not only are all local theatres playing a midnight show—yes, even the drive-in—but tomorrow’s “first day” screenings begin at 10:00am. It’s a Wednesday people. I understand it’s the summer and most kids are off of school, but one can imagine how many people lining up in the morning are playing hooky from work too. This thing will be breaking the bank for sure, despite the early, mostly derisive, reviews. The people that will be pumping money into Hollywood’s coffers aren’t likely to be reading those critical analyses anyway. No, instead they are probably going to see it again. In all honesty, I don’t blame them one bit. If I were a serious critic, looking at this thing in comparison with the great movies of all time, nitpicking every minute detail, I’d probably be hailing it as one of the worst motion pictures ever. But I am not, and I won’t. Transformers 2 is a heck of a lot of fun and I can say with a straight face that, if you enjoyed the first, you will have a blast with the second.
The movie brings what you’d expect from Bay—more of everything. There is a ton more action, mostly robot versus robot fighting, that intrigues immensely. I could have gone without the quips and stupid catchphrases as they throw each other, but that is a minor quibble. Even the comedic aspect is increased, and as someone who thought the first was too campy, this actually isn’t a bad thing. The humor is shored up and more honed with less headshaking and more laughing. Even little inside jokes thrown in, like a Bad Boys II poster hanging in Sam’s dorm room, sparks a chuckle. I was also beginning to think that John Turturro redeemed himself for a dismally weak performance in the first until they had to put him underneath a robot with two hanging metal orbs, to which he spoke over the radio, “I’m beneath the robot scrotum”. It was a very poor error in judgment, but, of course, the audience ate it up, along with the twins Mudflap and Skids. I don’t know what was more offensive, the ghetto-bots’ blatant caricature boarding on racist or the fact that every time Tyrese Gibson was on screen he was saying “that can’t be good”.
But Gibson wasn’t the only human left with nothing to do. In fact, besides Shia LaBeouf’s Sam Witwicky, every other real actor was relegated to being a two-dimensional prop. It’s a shame because by not having many people talk and exposing us to so many robots and sequences completely devoid of humans, you can’t help but notice how weak an actress Megan Fox is. It may be good that she is so under-utilized, because her real purpose is eye-candy, and that is the sad truth. I did enjoy Kevin Dunn and Julie White, reprising the Witwicky parents, but for the most part, all other actors were pretty much forgettable, especially the mostly annoying Ramon Rodriguez, going a bit too over the top too many times. I’ll give credit to LaBeouf, though, because “The Beef,” (why has that nickname stuck?), does deliver. This is the kind of role that he is perfect for: equal parts naïve, smart-mouthed kid with courageous, action hero instincts. You relate to a guy like him, (besides having the “every man’s dream” girlfriend that enjoys posing provocatively on motorcycles and hot-wiring cars, if you like that sort of thing), and believe that if he can save the world, you can too.
The true success here, however, is that the story revolves around the Transformers. If the first film was about Earth and humanity’s discovery of this alien race, the sequel is about that race and what it is they are doing here. It is a time for them to prove themselves and show that the trust humanity has given is earned. As a result, we get a ton of computer-generated robotics to brilliant effect. The robots came to Earth to harvest its sun for energy, only to discover life, realizing they must find another sun because they will not destroy a civilization. Except that one Prime decided to stay and reap the power, forever being called Fallen, exiled by the other Primes and blocked from his takeover. That means the Harvester is buried, the matrix key guarded, and Fallen is in hiding awaiting a chance to return. Once Sam touches a remnant of the All-Spark, well, the map to destruction is embedded in his head and the search for Earth’s survival is on. Yes, the mythology is convoluted, but if you buy into an alien race of robots coming to our world, well the plot will fall into place too.
So, yeah, the faults of the first are shored up pretty well, but the story loses something in the process. For being over two hours, the end comes with the realization that not much had happened, leaving us with an Optimus Prime voiceover, making us wonder if we accidentally just watched the first film again. Who goes to a Michael Bay film for the strong story, though, right? You go for a good time, an escape from the challenges of our world to watch the little guy defeat an impossible foe and save the world. Bay is the master of escapism and Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen is one more feather in his cap. You know what to expect and it will be delivered, so just sit back, relax, and enjoy a new adventure, much like the previous, but this time full of robotic goodness from front to back.
- Currently 3.0/5 Stars.