MUBI brings you a great new film every day.  Start your 7-day free trial today!
Watch a new film every day for $4.99.
Try MUBI for FREE.
 
All Topics  »

films with third-person narration

Brennan

about 3 years ago

There’s something about a dry, objective narration that lends any film a certain gravity. It always seems to evoke a somewhat detached, bittersweet feeling. The only films I can think of at the moment that use this device are The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford, Y Tu Mama Tambien, and Vicky Cristina Barcelona. I’d really like to know of others.

J.D.

about 3 years ago

One of my favorites is Alec Baldwin’s narration of The Royal Tenenbaums. That’s just the first one that came to mind. There are dozens more that I could probably think up. Godard does it all the time in his movies, most of the narration being done himself.

traag-1

about 3 years ago

Big Lebowski
It could happen to you
Dogville
Neverending story (kind of)
Europa (the amazing Max Von Sydow)
Royal Tenenbaums(alec Baldwin)
Anchorman
Magnolia

to name a few off the top of my head

Brennan

about 3 years ago

Yeah, I thought of Godard right after I posted, Dogville too. Traag, I don’t really count The Big Lebowski – though I may be wrong not to – simply because Sam Elliot does actually appear in it, and I was thinking specifically of films where the narrator is never named and never appears.

traag-1

about 3 years ago

isn’t named technically ;) but yeah I see your point :)

Tom Cavende​r

about 3 years ago

Others, off the top of my head:

A. I. (Ben Kingsley)
Hamlet 2 (Steve Coogan)
Mishima (Roy Scheider)
How the West Was Won (Spencer Tracy)

Also a couple with the narrator appearing at some point in the film
The Ten Commandments (1956) (Cecil B. DeMille)
Henry V (the Branagh version) (Derek Jacobi)

Kenji

about 3 years ago

Barry Lyndon, The Age of Innocence.

M I

about 3 years ago

The Magnificent Ambersons

Orson Welles’ narration in this movie is some of the best I’ve encountered. Royal Tenenbaums was heavily influenced, specifically the beginning.

Bruce

about 3 years ago

Welles’ television production, The Fountain of Youth, deals quite a bit in third person narration.

Frita Fuzzy Paws

about 3 years ago

With few exceptions I find objective narration to be intrusive and often lazy. It seems a literary crutch when a film maker cannot express a story in a visual way.

Ryan Estabro​oks

about 3 years ago

“Little Children” along with the others mentioned. I don’t mind the narration at all, I see film as more than just simply visuals. In fact, that’s the thing I love most about film, you can combine almost any art form into it: literary devices, music, paintings, etc.

Ben Simingt​on

about 3 years ago

Those couple of really distracting interruptions in INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS by Samuel L. Jackson. Not dry. Not objective. But third person. And totally useless in a movie that otherwise pretty much floored me.

Bruce

about 3 years ago

@Frita: A fashionable and lazy sentiment; film is medium that manipulates two senses, only one of which is the eyes. Why is it obligated to live its narrative life to half of its potential?

Brennan

about 3 years ago

Kenji – Yes! How could I forget barry Lyndon? Absolutely one of my favorite film narrations.
Frita- I understand that position, and I agree that it could be a crutch in the wrong hands, but when it’s used well – i.e. not simply describing what we’re seeing and telling us things we already know – I think it can provide insight and make for a richer experience. I certainly wouldn’t want it to become the norm though.

truefau​x

about 3 years ago

Jules et Jim

Ben Simingt​on

about 3 years ago

“I agree that it could be a crutch in the wrong hands, but when it’s used well – i.e. not simply describing what we’re seeing and telling us things we already know – I think it can provide insight and make for a richer experience.”

Yes. Of course it CAN be well used (EXTREMELY well used) when incorporated from the get-go of a film’s conceptualization. But of course this hardly ever happens, and we’re stuck with a ton of movies with cop-out voice-overs and last-minute-all-nighter-high-school-book-report-quality narrative structures cobbled together in the editing room. When it’s already too late.