So I have to once again disagree with most of the viewers in Mubi. This movie is not only the best Kim Ki-duk that I saw so far but also a masterpiece per se. Cinematography, Editing, Acting and Music creates the perfect atmosphere to take this movie out from any kind of cliche. Unfortunately, if we judge only the Story by itself it would not be so good. Thanks god that it is a movie, not a novel. So, amazing.

Seriously? What's wrong with everybody?! This just Hollywood with more Hollywood... nothing else... nothing special... at least acceptable for spending time...

I am not a very fan of writing opinions on internet because it seems pointless but after reading the comments about this movie i felt obligated to say that this is one of Hong Sang Soo's most strong script and will take a very different path from his other movies if you can watch it properly. If you have enough experiences in these kind of situations showed on the movie it will be very useful to understand as well.

worst kim ki duk film

UNfortunately, it could be better... but a really must see!

I can't see this movie without remeber the classic Mizoguchi movie, Suna no onna (Woman in the Dunes, in english). The plot is similar, but the execution quite different. Unfortunately, the japanese one is better.

Don't misunderstand me, I liked this movie, but, somehow, i know that everything made in this film was made someday before. I enjoyed all the 80 minutes, but still searching for all the good points that told me that the film had. A entertaining movie, but I think that's all for me.