A guy who has loved cinema since he was a child and has spent much of the rest of his life pursuing that love in an attempt to greater understand the medium and its complexities.
A guy who has loved cinema since he was a child and has spent much of the rest of his life pursuing that love in an attempt to greater understand the medium and its complexities.
I like that we seem to agree, in terms of value/enjoyment/quality on _Youth Without Youth_ and _2046_, two movies which, though they are certainly not universally abhorred, have been often dismissed based on (largely, I believe) the respective directors' previous works/acclaim. Additionally, your listing of _The Fire Within_ as a superlatively pleasing film has me wanting to see it more than I already do.
You're right, I misread the post below yours for yours; it included 2046 and 2001, both of which I had seen in your favorites, thus my mistake. My apologies. Seeing your actual choices, I have to think about them; they are certainly visually impressive, but not as easily classified (for me) as pleasing.
I can see the attraction to both _The Red Shoes_ and _Last Year at Marienbad_ (I have not seen _Vertigo_), but "Shoes" is, as you say, ostentatious (very theatrical: heavy makeup, garish colors--don't get me wrong, I really like the film, but it is what it is). "Marienbad", on the other hand, is definitely visually impressive, many shots, composed like paintings, and making good use of black and white for sculptural-like imagery, but its structure and pace, in a way, can obscure the aesthetics. They are not inconceivable choices, but they are interesting.
More than anything, I adore SHOES for its ballet sequence. It's such tremendous, exuberant spectacle, and genuine spectacle is nothing to sneer at. THE RED SHOES does not offer the depths present in some of the other Powell/Pressburger films, but it is the only one that enchants me. It plays to my fondness for the operatic (aside from film, opera is my favorite storytelling medium; that should speak volumes about my own sensibilities). MARIENBAD's uncanny quality goes a long way with me. But I am a Resnais fan through and through, from the heavier work of his earlier days to the more more joyful work of recent years. As far as I am concerned, he is the giant of the French New Wave. And you must see VERTIGO.
Operatic is actually a word I was thinking about using for _The Red Shoes_. Have you watched _The Tales of Hoffman_? While not quite as concentrated as the ballet sequence in _The Red Shoes_, given that it is a complete film composed of balletic sequences from Powell/Pressburger, you may enjoy it if you haven't already seen it. And in addition to watching -Vertigo_, I need to rewatch "Marienbad".
2 days ago
11 days ago
25 days ago
25 days ago
28 days ago
about 1 month ago
about 1 month ago