The Noteworthy: NYFCC Awards, "Doom", Defending Spike Lee's "Oldboy"

A new issue of Cléo, Adam Nayman on _Nebraska_, on-set photos from Gregg Araki's latest, a letter to Terrence Malick, and more.
Notebook

Edited by Adam Cook

 News.


Finds.

  • We haven't heard whispers about Scorsese's The Irishman for a while, but word is that it's slated to go in production after Silence.
  • For his blog, David Bordwell writes on "Hitchcock, Lessing, and the bomb under the table":

"I’ve wondered: Is this suspense/surprise distinction original with Hitchcock? In the tapes of the original interview with Truffaut, he notes: 'You know, there has always been this dispute between suspense and surprise. . . . What I’m saying is not new, I’ve said this many times before.' He then launches into a more expansive account of the bomb-table scenario.

His formulation is ambiguous. Is the distinction 'not new' because it’s been around a long while ('always'), or because he’s reiterated it many times? And is his preference for suspense an uncommon opinion? Exact answers may lie in the vast Hitchcock literature, but so far I haven’t found them. Here’s what I came up with."

"Despair. The weight of history, economics, moral failures, the back of one man, Louis Koo. The mise-en-scène and Koo. Probably as figural as To has ever been."

"Most of what’s good in Nebraska is also fairly obvious. Any praise it has received specifically for its subtlety has more to do with how skillfully Payne and his collaborators have applied a patina of subtlety—a good paint job—to the proceedings rather than any truly multifarious artistry. That’s not a knock, by the way: The Descendants (2011) was obvious too, written with a sledgehammer gracelessness, relentlessly hitting the nail on the head while missing the mark (and hey, guess what, it won an Academy Award for its script). The theme of Nebraska—that our parents were people before taking their places as all-powerful archetypes—is deep and resonant even if the homespun melodies laid over top of it are often tinny and thin."

  • While Spike Lee's Oldboy suffers from a weak box office performance and some rough words from most critics, The New Yorker's Richard Brody has a positive spin on the remake:

"Lee’s Oldboy is the most freakishly nerve-shredding Hollywood movie since Martin Scorsese’s Shutter Island, from 2010. While it’s not quite the grandly nuanced, historically intricate, psychologically shattering film that Scorsese’s is, Oldboy is a hectic, furious movie that sends a viewer into the street reeling with a sense of having seen something that is, in both senses, incredible—it’s an extreme artifice that, in its implausible plotting, seethes with the power of unbelievable truths. It’s also an intensely political film that, while avoiding the particulars of nuanced analysis, tears the lid off reasoned discourse to display the primal furies at stake in political conflict."

  • For Keyframe, David Hudson provides "an overview of the events and ideas that shaped the year in cinema."

From the archives.

  • Above: via zero focus, Jean-Luc Godard on the cover of Film Appreciation Journal (電影欣賞) published in Taiwan, 1989. Happy 83rd, JLG!

Don't miss our latest features and interviews.

Sign up for the Notebook Weekly Edit newsletter.

Tags

The NoteworthyNewsJohnnie ToMartin ScorseseGregg ArakiWes AndersonAlexander PayneDavid O. RussellPeter TscherkasskyClaire DenisSpike LeeJean-Luc Godard
7
Please sign up to add a new comment.

PREVIOUS FEATURES

@mubinotebook
Notebook is a daily, international film publication. Our mission is to guide film lovers searching, lost or adrift in an overwhelming sea of content. We offer text, images, sounds and video as critical maps, passways and illuminations to the worlds of contemporary and classic film. Notebook is a MUBI publication.

Contact

If you're interested in contributing to Notebook, please see our pitching guidelines. For all other inquiries, contact the editorial team.