Porumboiu found here an extremely deft way to make an impossibly grand statement without getting the least bit heavy about it. Not heavy until the end. This thing is dry-ass funny wisdom until the culminating karate chop to the throats of its three stooges. And us. We are made to choke on our laughter. All laughter, since forever: to laugh from inside the nightmare of history because no nightmare is all nightmare.
This is a positive two stars! An uneven but heartfelt 'comedy' about the political phenomenon of memory. It's split approximately in half; the first I liked a lot, and the second I found frequently interesting. Then, a really really beautiful coda that just left me feeling contemplative. I enjoyed this one! Regret not watching it right near Christmas tho :/ Perhaps next year...
It's snowing big white flakes, enjoy it now, tomorrow it will be mud. Whether or not this small Romanian town was active in the revolution seems depressingly irrelevant. All we get is forced narrative or anticlimactic truth. A funny and sardonic film.
Did the revolution truly bring positive change? Often it appears revolutions do not, and Porumboiu questions this in a drab post-communist environment full of decaying infrastructure and individuals. Even further he asks was there even a revolution? Was there anyone really brave enough to even challenge the old regime? With whimsical dark humor Porumboiu questions even this as the blurriness of history is asserted.
Richly deadpan and droll meditation on the very distinctive Eastern European modus of collective memory and cultural identity. I enjoyed the interactions of the main characters; throughout, the lead actors hit just the right note. NIce editing. A key entry in the Romanian New Wave canon.
A beautiful, brutally ironic film. Despite the revolution, some people still choose to interrogate and persecute others as though sitting on the old tribunals. Loved the beginning, when we see the position of women has not advanced. Graceful, honest remembrance at the end by the older fellow is perfect counterpart to all the inane political posturing that comes before.
There is much to appreciate about Corneliu Porumboiu's direction of this winningly naturalistic farce, from the Tarkovskian follow-shot of a Christmas tree-laden car, to the amateurish camera work which takes over the latter half of the film. The film is a sly takedown of the insular, self-important worldview of life in a small town.
This was a very interesting film, with some outstandingly funny and very interesting moments. I felt like it dragged a big at the beginning, but the second half was quite well done. If it would've started into the talk show itself earlier, and allowed that section of the movie to play out for longer I think I'd have enjoyed it more.
At first I wasn't too intrigued, but as the story progresses, it only gets better and better. The final sequence is by far the highlight of the entire film. As another reviewer stated, I wish it could have gone on forever! Hilarious and incredibly charming.
Fantastic! Gets to the heart of the human dimension of political processes. Recent European history is complicated enough. But throw in the vanities, insecurities and uncertainties of every day folk, and you have a web that's impossible to untangle. And still, the film finds humor in all of it.
Flawlessly written, brilliantly economical gray comedy about the snowball effect of human pettiness and the chaos that ensues when we examine our most cherished illusions too closely. Fantastic performances by all three leads. Despite its extreme staticness, the camera always seems to be just where it should be. Great example of the knack of former Eastern Bloc filmmakers for making the bleak beautiful.