Intersting touch on social aspect of revolution, somewhat less convincing than say Tunisia Clash. The end bit is a bit formulaic, and as such disappointing. Also, I have the feeling that the hand that is feeding the project is always apparent at the corner of the shot. The divide between revolutionaries and common people is likely underrepresented by quite a bit.
An interesting look at a turbulent time in Egypt's recent history, and also the price paid by expendable soldiers who may not fully understand just how much their lives will be affected by acts of war. Solid lead performances help, and patient viewers should feel rewarded by the characterisations and the sketching of what is permitted and what is frowned upon socially.
I was going for 3 stars for most of the film, but the poignant, allegorical ending turned it into a 4 for me. The romance wasn't quite convincing and there were moments, in the beginning especially, that confused me, but it tackles political and social divides in ways that are very resonant around the world today.
The impact of revolution on daily lives. Class divide and gender politics. Revolution = no tourists. No tourists = no livelihood/ Tahir: "We went to defend our livelihood"/ "No, you went to fight against revolution". Poetically presented this film is not storytelling, but life portraying, a good education for westerners. Shot with honesty. No breaking down to explain the culture. You have to watch and learn.
Magnificent picture with a strong documentary base that its narrative developed from featuring amazing performances from its two leads, Menna Chalaby and Bassem Samra. Starting with an incident in Tahrir Square and ending with a march on the generals months later the film investigates both the hope and the hopelessness generated by revolution amongst both sides of the class divide. Raw, passionate and revealing.