Pas mauvais (surtout après Thor dans le MCU!), visuellement réussi, mais trop de lacunes empêchent d'apprécier le film à son plein potentiel. Le montage et le son sont assez mauvais, le montage, trop rapide, et le scénario ridicule est rattrapé par des performances d'acteur assez louables. Au final un film de super-héros plutôt réussi, mais la formule est trop prévisible pour être vraiment gagnante.
Excellent retro superhero action situated in WW2. A perfect fit for it's director who already made another film in the same style ("The Rocketeer"). Hayley Atwell and Chris Evans give the movie a heart and are wonderful to behold. Some origin elements at the beginning feels too familiar with other superhero movies and the ending is anti-climatic but this is still an excellent entry to the superhero genre.
Marvel films are at their best when they are standalone, not trying to shoehorn as many characters as possible into the plot. This is a very solid caper - effectively Indiania Jones with soldiers and silly Nazis. The final scene feels tacked on - I would have used it to open Avengers.
Retro in every sense of the word - a fine script that clips along at a welcome pace, characters that each suggest a need for heroism, and excellent set pieces to get us there. The Carter/Rogers relationship was a highlight. When Cap stumbles onto Times Square circa 2010, I really did feel teleported into the future. And kinda bummed I wasn't punching cartoon Nazis anymore.
It's at its best when it reminds one of a Spielbergian action film-- akin to Indiana Jones-- with its period setting, farce humor, and the humanistic characterization of Evans. It's at its worse when it reminds one of melodrama-heavy hokum in its cartoony villain and a second half that halts the emotion for heavy-handed action. However, Evans last scene with Atwell is tender, and the final scene is clever.
Marvel has changed the game for how comic books are brought to the screen. They may not all be Citizen Kane but they do the material justice and they are entertaining and they have brought everything together in a beautiful fashion. If only they could get back the rights to everything else.