The mystery case was so lazy and nonsensical, it made the six-armed musician and the flying killer robots were the most logical things in this. WHY ANDY LAU WHY?? In the end, this movie could only be explained with the greatest word in Indonesian vocabulary: LEBAY.
(Vu Kekparsurleweb) Distrayant sur le moment, aussitôt oublié. Une production lisse et sans génie comme il y en a tant parmi les films d'action chinois en ce moment...Comme d'habitude, Tsui Hark abuse trop des câbles pour les cascades, mais sa mise en scène semble (et c'est pour le mieux) un peu plus lisible que d'habitude ici.
Hark's dedication to (intentionally) bad CGI is kind of radical in a deconstructive sense, but also a problem, denying the brilliant martial arts choreography of Sammo Hung some of its natural, visceral energy. Nonetheless, it's a remarkable film, employing a genuinely interesting murder mystery narrative, with sidelines into political conspiracy & magical realism, with the bold & expressive stylisation of the Wuxia.
Never boring Tang dynasty story resulting in a strange hybrid of genres for this Tsui Hark effort. Tsui's most interesting film in years, perhaps since Time and Tide or his under-rated remake The Blade. Visually sumptious with fine work by dp Chan and excellent rendering and matte work. Performances vary but film contains a great show by Carina Lau as the empress. Andy Lau always watchable but acting here is thin.
Not at all like the great series of mystery novels by Robert van Gulik, but rather much like a Chinese version of the Guy Ritchie/Robert Downey, Jr. Sherlock Holmes movies, in which a great detective character is placed in the middle of some gigantic souped-up plot. Tsui is in great form, with fabulous vistas and flabbergasting plot points (e.g. the statue, spontaneous human combustion, and the deer).
An extremely fun and entertaining movie. I like my chinese action movies exactly like this: over the top. The scene where the main character has to fight off possessed deer makes the whole movie worth it. That being said it is truly beautifully shot with spectacular production design. Pure entertainment.
What a film. Beautiful in every way, camera, sets, and costume. Well acted with a distinctly western flavor. Based on the, Van Gulick novels, the film goes places they only hint at. So satisfied was I, that I went out and bought it. If you like, Chinese Historical films, you will love it. It has intrigue, action, spooky deer, a magical mace, and a very clever detective. See it and let me know what you think.
Kind of ridiculous only in that kung-fu epic sort of way that's both serious and outrageous. The fight sequences are great but the story seemed to suffer from being a bit muddled. I guess without the historical context applied to the film, the characters played a little flat, even Detective Dee himself. Still fun though some awful CGI does hurt the film. It just looks bad and unconvincing.