Unabashedly trashy. Yu plays every lame joke with a straight face and even heightens the artifice by indulging in the explosive potential of these immortal screen bodies. The most recurrent image, of bodies flying through the air (across distances so great they must be conveyed across multiple cuts), signals back to neither of the two horror franchises but Tex Avery cartoons & their cartoonish, elastic metaphysics.
You know what? This is a blast from beginning to end and they put a good deal more effort into setting up the smackdown than I expected. Obviously it's trash but it's grand fun for a horror fan and I'm deeply saddened that this didn't lead to more monster match-ups of this ilk.
This was a film I thoroughly enjoyed as a kid. Growing up I was a huge fan of the Nightmare on Elm Street franchise and I thought Freddy Kruger was one of the most badass villains of all time and seeing these two horror titans square off in a no holds barred game of cat and mouse was an absolute delight for the geek in everyone.
Of course bad films are always being made, but FvJ seems especially emblematic of a period when gross films were being made. Circa 2000's was probably the worst time for comedies/horrors marketed to millennial teens who were seen to desire something edgier. The result is distasteful trash like this, with a distinct lack of the fun or wit which drove the Nightmare series. This shit makes 'New Nightmare' look golden.