So my contention was that Pacino was a better actor than DeNiro. The problem was that Pacino lost his mind after his early triumphs and decided to eat the scenery. He calmed down a bit for this movie. At this time DeNiro was actually ahead, but for this movie I think it was a tie. Of course now DeNiro is way overexposed. I still think if you compare the best of both actors Pacino wins. "Attica! Attica!"