If the music isn't good, I just don't care how good the movie is. One of the best songs in the movie is "Come what may", which should have won the Oscar, were it not disqualified for stupid reasons. While Nicole Kidman is picture perfect, it's Ewan McGregor who really steals the show. He does a great cover of "Your Song".
1-2. A stupid, tone-deaf, overblown, self-aggrandizing , epileptic, Id-driven cartoon. And yet I kind of enjoyed it up to a point. There's a certain cheap thrill in the cartoony sex jokes and pop song rearrangements. But the movie works really hard to hammer its theme home, and the underdeveloped drama becomes a lot more pronounced in the second half. And that definitely drains a lot of the fun away.