Para disfrutar de una experiencia mejor en MUBI, Actualiza tu buscador

Ratings & Reviews

  1. Hope Morrison's rating of the film New York Stories

    blah. woody allens was pretty funny, but the two before can do one (vilify me scorsese fans - his characters sucked, just exploitative and glorifying of a pretty grim type of relationship and man)

  2. graceblessington's rating of the film New York Stories

    The Scorsese film that comes first is a bit convincing, but overall unnecessary. The Coppola film is unspeakable. The Allen film was overdone and just plain stupid.

  3. Duncan Gray's rating of the film New York Stories

    Scorsese's is about the seductive mirage of the art life, as energetically shot and edited as anything he's done, with a terrific ending. Coppola's is the embarrassment of a legend, but useful today as the interesting juvenilia of his co-writer Sofia. And Woody Allen's is Woody Allen. A testament to directors 1 and 3 that they bail out director 2. On the whole, this shows that a short format is its own opportunity.

  4. dionysus67's rating of the film New York Stories

    A hugely uneven portmentau film by some of New American Cinema's most respected directors. Clearly, more thought and cinematic flair should have been put into this rather spineless outcome. The Scorsese story is really the only one that justifies the prestige of the three names involved and the one with a cinematic perspective proper. Coppola's vehicle for Sophie is unwatchable and Allen is a shadow of his good self.

  5. Ulrich JARLØV's rating of the film New York Stories

    Coppola's segment is a disaster, Woody's segment is slight and quickly forgotten. Scorsese's segment is a masterpiece - 5 stars for that gem alone.

  6. Diego Ruscitto's rating of the film New York Stories

    Life Lessons: 3/5 Life Without Zoë: 2/5 Oedipus Wrecks: 4/5

  7. ninchok's rating of the film New York Stories

    Woody Allen is a genius. And it's also very stupid that people criticize both Scorsese's and Coppola's segments; I think they were all good. Though I loved Coppola's one more, Scorsese did a masterful work nonetheless.

  8. Leif Erikson's rating of the film New York Stories

    So I'll take care of it. You can drop the case. Yeah don't find her. Don't look for her anymore.

  9. Joao Sobral's rating of the film New York Stories

    Woody Allen short is 4/5 Coppola 3/5 Scorsese 2/5

  10. Christopher McQuain's rating of the film New York Stories

    LIFE LESSONS: ****. LIFE WITHOUT ZOE: **1/2. OEDIPUS WRECKS: ****1/2.

  11. Dalibor's rating of the film New York Stories

    It seems only Scorsese saw this, quite plain but potentially interesting concept of a three 40-something minute shorts on New York, as an opportunity for a new and intriguing look at Big Apple, as Coppola tried out a bunch of ideas he probably had in store, that together didn't come out as a cohesive narrative or a decent plot even, and Allen pretty much does his usual, not so inspired, routine.

  12. Fabio Osvaldo Carta's rating of the film New York Stories

    È impossibile da rateare perché il segmento di Coppola fa seriamente cagare e gli altri due sono simpatici

  13. FISCHER's rating of the film New York Stories

    Trois sketches : "Apprentissages", "La vie sans Zoe" et "le complot d'Oedipe" par trois réalisateurs confirmés tournant autour de la ville de New York ..... Plutôt moyen ! www.cinefiches.com

  14. William's rating of the film New York Stories

    3.5 Scorsese's segment is truly outstanding and Woody's is fun; Coppola's middle section gets a bad rap, but its focus on the lives of rich 12 year olds is actually quite amusing and well-done; the biggest flaw lies in how its low-key approach upsets the rhythms of the other two. Perhaps most importantly, witness the holy trifecta of cinematographers on display here: Almendros, Storaro & Nykvist!

  15. Lynch/Fellini's rating of the film New York Stories

    Martin Scorsese and Woody Allen made good shorts. I don't know what Francis Ford Coppola was thinking when he made his, probably his worst film after Jack.

  16. Ege Okal's rating of the film New York Stories

    Scorsese's interpretation of the NY art world seems to be cliche but funnily on the spot!Constant gaze and graze of the camera is perfect to depict the young hot muse fetish of the old & famous (tortured) male artist. Coppola's story probably is based on semi-Eloise semi-daughter Sofia.It's the weakest film in the bunch but I understand the snob but naive girlish approach. Woody Allen's part is just brilliantly anal.

  17. wiwitaek's rating of the film New York Stories

    Dull. Only Woody Allen's segment makes the movie worth watching

  18. H. K. ‡'s rating of the film New York Stories

    I'm not surprised that Scorsese's narcissistic male fantasy (with its defensive and pandering satire failing completely) receives endless praise while Coppola's segment—a parable that explores the inner life of a young girl—is dismissed as trivial. Such a reception typifies the critical acceptance and privileging of the male gaze.

  19. zdravk3's rating of the film New York Stories

    1st part is really cool (5 stars), you can skip the rest

  20. Ryan O'Connor (23)'s rating of the film New York Stories

    woody allen's was probably the best segment.

  21. Tudor Rachieru's rating of the film New York Stories

    4 stars-Martin Scorsese; 1 star-Francis Coppola; 5 stars-Woody Allen

  22. galuh indri's rating of the film New York Stories

    Woody Allen is so Woody Allen as always. But this time my favorite would be Scorsese's.

  23. Dignan's rating of the film New York Stories

    New York Stories should be titled Opulent and Odious Stories. This is New York from the point of view of three extremely wealthy and aloof filmmakers. I forgive Woody Allen for his Kafkaesque story because it's imaginative and funny. But I don't feel good about it.

  24. Sasha Mlick's rating of the film New York Stories

← Previous 1 3