Viene sapientemente messa alla berlina l'insensatezza e la brutalità della guerra. Bella trama e grande protagonista idealista, che pian piano viene corrotto. La brutalità e l'imbarbarimento dell'uomo sono stati resi benissimo. Ottime le scene di conflitto, con alcuni momenti eccezionali. Il ritmo è molto buono. I rapporti fra i commilitoni sono ben strutturati e appassionano.Regia e fotografia ispirate e curatissime
Nice ensemble cast full of career-starting roles and a great one by Willem Dafoe. The monologues are too on-the-nose to the point that they sound vaguely preachy. The visual effects leave a lot to be desired too, breaking the suspension of disbelief almost continuously. Almost 30 years after its release, it just doesn't hold up to the test of time.
One of the best war movie about Vietnam War - along with Coppola's Apocalypse Now and Kubrick's Full Metal Jacket. Oliver Stone gave us a nightmarish depiction of Vietnam War. Just like what Charlie Sheen's character said about the war, Stone also succeed to make the war in this movie like hell. He didn't forget to give a deeper characterization to each characters. Not to mention, that "famous" Willem Dafoe scene...
I could never really relate to war films, even less to war films about Vietnam. But Oliver Stone's Platoon is compelling to watch, and this tale of innocence lost is made even more poignant by the great cast - Charlie Sheen, Willem Dafoe Forest Whitaker to Johnny Depp, and forces the audience to face the tragic pointlessness of Manichean thinking.
Stone is a cinematic maximalist, for better or worse. Platoon's influence on war films is unmistakeable, but it lacks the poetic psychological depth of Malick's 'The Thin Red Line' or the haunting grace of Kubrick's 'Paths of Glory'. Iconic and distinctive (like many Stone films) but also a film in caps lock.
A solid, competent war movie, nothing more, nothing less. There's nothing wrong with it, per se, but there are just so many "war is hell" movies that you really need something special or distinct to stand out and this one had nothing, nothing I haven't seen many times before. This gets an unremarkable C.
I'm actually a little unsure about how I feel about this movie. Obviously it has great battle scenes but in my mind the relationship between Taylor, Elias and Barnes wasn't what it could've been... Other than that the usual moral dilemma's that come with war were portrayed nicely. Personally I like the more conceptual war movies though like Apocalypse Now and The Thin Red Line.
The plot is essentially cliffnotes of all the terrible things that went on during Vietnam, coupled with hilarious 1 dimensional caricatures of the 'good' soldiers who smoked weed and waxed philosophical and 'bad' soldiers who were drunk racists who loved war. War is far too complicated to be reduced to a 1 note tune that's just at propagandic as many terrible war films made during WWII.