It's far for being one of the best Vidor's work, still is a magnificent film and he completely broke my heart. Just a few women I could compare to Barbara Stanwyck (All that heaven allows, Imitation of Life, Mamma Roma, Mater Dolorosa or Mildred Pierce are rare exception), still is hard to find a more beautiful film about motherhood.
One of Stanwyck's great performances. Very few can match her. Contemporary actresses intellectualize (sometimes brilliantly) but Stanwyck just lives it. I think her closest modern equivalent is Debra Winger, who isn't so modern anymore. Maybe Jennifer Lawrence, a bit?
Interesting in anthropological and social terms, though I didn't feel the lead female character was very strong at all. The crescendo building up at the beginning of the film, with Stella dreaming outside of her bounds, only led to show her superficial nature right until the end. But the developing mother-daughter relationship is really beautiful to watch, particularly the lesson on self-sacrifice.
First rate melodrama underpinned by a wry critique of the idle rich and their conventions. A heartbreaking tale of wisdom painfully won by a social climber at odds with the confining and contradictory rules of the elite. Despite all the trappings of excess, less indeed seems to be more in this world. In stark contrast, Stella conspicuously bubbles over with elan, life and love for her daughter. Stanwyck is stunning.
Remarkably unconventional drama which gradually builds into a tragic melodrama by defying any traditional structures and remaining seemingly plotless for at least the first half. Instead it develops a number of unique and respectful relationships which confound expectations and ultimately function as either a film about the sacrifice of motherhood or the corrosive nature of class. Empowering and very moving.
Beautiful and complex characters. Wonderful expressions of love and relationships, mother daughter, parent, child - society, "bettering ourselves" - survival. So fantastically captured in stunning camera shots. Focused so brilliantly on the eyes of these inspiring actors in so many moments, the eyes tell us all. In every stride, and flick of her fur, Barbara Stanwyck IS Stella Dallas.
One of Stanwyck's essential performances, which automatically makes this a must-see, but it is also one of Hollywood's toughest and most emotionally complex melodramas. Stanwyck portrays Stella's many facets not as different characters, but as murky shades of the same complex woman, and, as a result, provides the emotionally consistency the film needs to make its tear-jerking moments work. And boy do they work.
The story is nothing amazing but Barbara Stanwyck's performance and King Vidor's direction are worth the watch. The last 20 minutes are incredibly heartbreaking so have the box of Kleenex handy. I'd describe Stella Dallas as the nicer cousin of Mildred Pierce and Of Human Bondage. If none of these things are a draw for you, save yourself the time...