Surprisingly, a dud. Endless grey monologues, pointless side-plots, key uncharismatic performances from, to start with, Hill and Otto. None of the wistful earthiness and even passion of the first film (perhaps due to the absence of Bean and Holm). Brad Dourif's small role as Grima Wormtongue is so good that the film plunges into dullness on his departure. The reliablity of Wood and Astin bring the only solidity.