Minor, unessential Kurosawa, but even at his seemingly simplest, he gives us a nice little suspense and creation. Only his fourth film, "Tiger's Tail" has some really silly acting, although the mise en scene is lovely to watch...but Rashomon or even the Seven Samurai it ain't,
Well, it's a Kurosawa. Far from its bests, but still a Kurosawa. It's elegant, the music is great, the story is very good (even though a little Wikipedia search helped understand the whole context of the story, that's originally a Kabuki play about how a Buddhist monk betray his principles for the sake of his Prince). The carrier adds some antagonizing comedy that reliefs the whole seriousness. Worth, as usual.
3,5/5 Très surprenant film à la structure dramatique inattendue (la fin !), au mélange des tons tranché (l'étonnant comique jeu du porteur ; quasiment du No...), au tournage en extérieurs de studio (ça s'entend !), aux commentaires chantés... De toute manière, mieux vaut marcher sur la queue du tigre plutôt que sur celle du panda !
Early work from Kurosawa. Not exactly spectacular, but he manages to build a nice tension with little effects. A game of poker where nobody, in the end, can consider himself a winner. The stage aspect of it, very Kabuki-like, kind of disturbed me and did not age particularly well.
On ne peut pas dire que cette oeuvre courte, qui subit à la fois la censure américaine et japonaise, apporte quoique ce soit à la gloire du grand réalisateur. Pas vraiment de quoi s'enthousiasmer dans cette histoire qui reste ancrée dans la pensée et le "folklore" nippons... www.cinefiches.com
Back to basics. Proof that in order to create classic art, you must be free of the constraints of a populist agenda. In this concise masterpiece, Kurosawa returns to the optimistic melodramatic voice which made him great. Here, a sense of brotherhood is better pronounced than in 7 SAMURAI. The flower symbolism is present, as are classic and archetypal characters. The story is pushed along by great wiped transitions.
Out of all his films made during WII this would have to be my favorite. If the film kept a completely faithful look at the Kabuki/Noh drama then this film would've been just an adequate & straightforward film. However the inclusion of the porter, played brilliantly by Enomoto, brings the film to life with his scene-stealing performance that undercuts the seriousness of the source material.
It's only 1 hour, looks low budget, you can tell they are on a soundstage instead of outside. But you have some CLASSIC Kurosawa shots and characters. It was like a short live action black and white Anime. Especially the scene with the "Nine-Syllable-Mantra" special move that SCENE (you know what I'm talking about) is on some fuckin crazy anime shit! Not the best Kurosawa film, but a MUST-SEE for fans! Watch it!
Esta adaptación de una obra de teatro kabuki representa la única incursión de Kurosawa en los terrenos de la comedia. Entre otros de sus colaboradores habituales, la cinta está protagonizada por Kenichi Enomoto, una especie de antecesor japonés de Jim Carrey (e igual de detestable). Una obra menor (aunque con una edición brillante) que resulta ser toda una curiosidad dentrode la filmografía del notable realizador.