Great cinematography and pacing, the music is way too kitschy and cliché. I enjoyed the acting of Q’orianka Kilcher, she was the strongest of the three main characters. But the fact, that she was 14, when this movie was is deeply troubling. Which is one reason why the whole romantic storylinie didn't work at all for me.
This is a masterpiece of the cinema. Malick invokes the spirit of Stanley Kubrick and Andrei Tarkovsky with this underrated gem that is hauntingly beautiful and like any other Malick film it has the ability to suck you in no matter how mundane the things on the screen are. Q'orianka Kilcher is an absolute delight of beauty and talent and her grace is what makes this film great.
This really is testament to a vision. Testament by way of insane commitment. This is cinema practiced by a company of outliers-by-default. There is only one director directing anything like Terrence Malick movies. Though they inspire awe, however, I do not think The New World and The Tree of Life will age as well as his more recent contemporary-set stuff. There's just this aggressive sense of adults playing dress-up.
Disappointing, in a word. I have come to the conclusion that just because Terrence Malick made one of my all time favorite movies, I'm not sure he qualifies as one of my favorite directors. Half of his work that I've seen I've loved (Badlands, The Thin Red Line, The Tree of Life), the other half considerably less so (Days of Heaven, this, To the Wonder).
A sweeping love-story where settlers and natives intertwine. An intimate picture of three people in need of love rather than a search of place which contrasts Europe and America. The movie doesn't have a pace but it flows like waves on shore. Although the sound design brings the nature into my living room I actually missed hearing more of the James Horner soundtrack.
The first Terence Malick film I'd ever seen, I saw it when it came out. My 12 year old mind couldn't really comprehend all the long shots, and I just thought of it as essentially the Oscar version of Pochahontas. That said, it's one of the more mainstream Malick films.
I think this was a really interesting direction for Mallick to go, it makes sense considering his take on narratives from a vey romantic, inter-human, head meets heart meets nature point of view. It's a story the world knows well, told with a new sense of justice through Malick's hyper-authentic style. Loved the voice overs being more in the moment for a change rather than the usual liberated thoughts.
Malick's approach is inevitably quite frustrating to people who watch his films & choose to focus on banal dramatic conventions such structure & storyline rather than their metaphysical ambitions. The central question that runs through all of Malick's films is "What is man's relationship to nature?" In the New World, he gives us what is arguably his definitive answer, the sum total of his life as a filmmaker.