Really not a very good musical. Kelly just feels miscast as a pirate. Garland and Kelly's musical numbers are fine though and keep this from being a total bore. I admire Minnelli and co for trying to make a musical that wasnt in the MGM tradition, unfortunately the result is just so so. Recommended for some of the musical numbers though
Wow. The Pirate is so much fun. It's such a wonderfully entertaining film - Gene Kelly is absolutely electric, the Technicolor is as beautiful as anywhere else, and the entire experience is carried along by a marvellously tongue-in-cheek love story. Brilliant. I don't generally go for musicals, but The Pirate is a great motion picture.
Judy Garland plays Manuela, a girl betrothed to the much older mayor, who (unknown to her) in his younger days was the very Pirate by whom she now dreams of being abducted. When she is placed under hypnosis by a traveling player, Serafin played by Gene Kelly, she lets loose with a song that seeks to encompass and express her vast sensual longings. It's the best of film musicals and Mac the Black is its very heart.