This was definitely a unique experience. A movie with no dialogue, no subtitles, no soundtrack. A movie all in ukranian sign language. The camera gives you a seat - you're only the spectator, you're at a distance watching that specific reality unfold. It is mesmerizing, violent, but truly immersive. Beware, this movie is not about deaf people. It's about people. It could have happen anywhere..and it does.
The Tribe, with its lack of translation, proves how stories can be well told purely through visuals and sound. Vasyanovych's cinematography stuns with every scene that stands on its own as a single shot, structured in a parallelistic way and framed to perfection. The disturbingly slow action and the shocking brutality of the film is something that's rarely shown in cinema but that's what makes it real and unusual!
A film that manages to win each of its battle and to lose the war. The tactical successes of scenes sounding true, and of horrible mostly interchangeable people interacting violently, fails as there is no strategic end to the game. This could be poignant parallels to Ukraine political situation but they feel accidental. Certainly in the spirit of the time for a part of Ukrainian society today.
Very impressive. This film did more in 34 shots and almost total silence than most do full of camerawork and dialog. While I feel a lot of the story was at times rushed, and that I probably missed a lot because I was left to only deduce what was happening for most of it, the way the intensity was amped up using only acting is enough for me to have loved this.
The concept is better than the actual story. There are wonderfully exciting moments but mostly it seems like an amazing concept with cheap shocking thrills that have been handled better in other films. There were also too many moments where the crew didn't understand that their shadows and reflections would show up in the film if they weren't careful. An amazing idea with a cheap story.
The only reason I wouldn't give this five stars is the fact that I'm torn by the progression of Sergey as a character, and I know that's due to the nonverbal communication creating a language barrier for me as a viewer; It was incredible watching all the events unfold absent dialogue, and the story told me everything I technically needed to know through action alone; but I couldn't connect to Sergey's psyche.
Man stelle sich vor, irgendwo auf der Welt befände sich eine Spezies, die vollkommen unerkannt exisitiert. Was würdest du als Filmemacher damit anfangen? Nicht mehr als eine Art Remake von Kids? Irgendwann, als mir bewusst wurde, dass The Tribe nichts anderes ist als ein östliches Remake von Kids ohne Worte... mehr auf cinegeek.de
Devastante,un vero cazzotto in faccia.Sembra un pò il primo Korine,quello che raccontava il marciume in Kids,ma lo stile minimalista europeo lo rende ancora più asettico e freddo.All'inizio vola basso,poi deflagra piano piano in un crescendo di intensità e violenza:l'aborto è lacerante,lo stupro è uno dei più belli mai visti (poi il silenzio aumenta ancor di più l'empatia) ed il finale è un macigno addosso. Sbom.
It first occurred to me, when watching the music video for Faithless' "Insomnia", that deaf-mute people can also have 'loud' discussions and strong emotions. I'm not gonna lie, a film with no spoken dialogue or soundtrack, should have been edited to be a little shorter, however misery and violence seemed to be emphasised by the lack of these sounds, creating a very austere and brutal experience for the viewer.