I'm on their side, but again, like the Michael Moore doc, I'm bothered by the one-sidedness. To be honest though, I'm not sure it's really that wrong to be one-sided in a work of art or opinion. Aren't works of art their own personal worldview, and doesn't every worldview stem from an inherent opinion? Anyway, I think I would personally rather watch the debates they pull clips from.
People will have mixed opinions about the film due to its theme. But being a cause that I am deeply associated with I think it is a worth watch for those who are either rational or on the brink of it... You cannot call it a film marvel of any sort, I would give it 3 for its important theme and not the film making
A Dawkins and Krauss road movie comprised of sound bites, location establishing shots, and travel footage, culminating in a collection of soundbites from other celebrities at the Reason Rally in Washington, D.C. The cinematographer gets to play with selective focus a lot to keep shots of cities and conveyances interesting, but that only goes so far. There's a great deal too http://letterboxd.com/mharbour/films/diary/
Don't get me wrong: I believe religion should be destroyed and that universal secularism is urgent to the future of our species and society. However, how many of these Dawkinmentaries can be made? Sure, it's fun to hear witty ways of ridiculing the religious and a blast to hear people wax poetic about science, but this will merely preach to its choir. It's not productive, nor creative, and doesn't try to be.