With films like Network, Dog Day Afternoon and 12 Angry Men under his belt Sidney Lumet has quite the career. However, with "The Verdict" Lumet might have managed to make his best film yet! Newman gives an great performance. He is vulnerable and weak, but at the same time he has a strange strength. It also helps that this film is very reminiscent of one of my favorite films Otto Preminger's Anatomy of a Murder!
Three things: 1) Master director at the top of his form; 2) as uncompromising and not-very-glamorous a performance from a Hollywood star of the oldschool as you are ever likely to see (Fonda in ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST notwithstanding); 3) screenplay that imparts information in a remarkably sophisticated manner (at least for awhile). Will say, though: the Mata Hari business is a bit of a hard swallow (and lame).
Quite common premise of an off-course lawyer opposing the unjust judicial system is presented in two ways. By an equally common script, however impeccably paced, missing a few targets. And by director's genuine craftsmanship, creating space, characters and tension through unobtrusive but constantly ambitious camera-work.
the cons: frank galvin is... underwhelming and his charm wanes. the silent, brooding, wünderkind alcoholic schtick gets old after the first 30 minutes. i really dislike that laura fischer (rampling) is essentially galvin's mirror. the pros: incredible shots (pay attention to camera angle when you watch it), a gripping story with ample pathos. overall: a finely crafted product that could've done more.
We are really suffering from a script, what would seem to be a perfect marriage is just crass and unsure of its social impact. Lumet is nevertheless quite the filmmaker, and he gives us quite a shadowy film, with a fantastic way of letting rooms, spaces, expand and retract as is fitting for the drama. Tense in unexpected ways. oh, Charlotte Rampling is in this, for very little time. Newman owns the movie, I guess.
Un Lumet in forma strepitosa.Lo script non mi suggeriva nulla di nuovo e il plot seguiva linee abbastanza definite,ma ciò che mi ha emozionato è stata l'incredibile abilità di Lumet di gestire gli spazi,di dosare i tempi e creare atmosfere intriganti solo con i movimenti e la posizioni di scena.Un Newman TITANICO regge alla grande il film,e contribuisce molto ad un'ottima pellicola di un regista meraviglioso.