2008, Ranked

Synecdoche, New York: A+
Slumdog Millionaire: A+
The Dark Knight: A
WALL-E: A
The Wrestler: A
Repo! The Genetic Opera: A
The Class: A
Frost/Nixon: A
The Visitor: A
Gomorrah: A
Rachel Getting Married: A
Defiance: A
In Bruges: A-
Iron Man/Hellboy II: A-
Recount: A-
Milk: A-
Elegy: A-
Burn After Reading: A-
Gran Torino: A-
W.: A-
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button: A-
Che: Part One: A-
Happy-Go-Lucky: A-
Tropic Thunder: A-
Forgetting Sarah Marshall: A-
Hamlet 2: A-
American Teen: A-