Film: The Critics’ Choice is a book from 2001, edited by Geoff Andrew, with a selection of 150 films, 10 (well 11, with a pair) distinguished critics each picking 15 films to cover a different era or aspect of cinema
David Bordwell: The Silent Era (#1-15)
David Thomson: America: The Studio Years (16-30)
Philip French: America: Years of Change (31-45)
Amy Taubin and Kent Jones: America: The Modern Era (46-60)
Gilbert Adair: Europe: The Golden Age (61-75)
Jonathan Rosenbaum: Europe: New Waves (76-90)
Jonathan Romney: Europe: A New Fin de Siecle (91-105)
Peter Wollen: British Cinema (106-120)
Tony Rayns: International Cinema (121-135)
Paul Wells: the Art of the Impossible (136-149)
A few observations:
- Latin America is neglected in the book (and the book’s use of the term America is problematic)
- Where is India?
- World Cinema generally could have done with more extensive coverage, an extra chapter could have done wonders, and so Africa would have been better served too
- In our Auteurs Film World Cup, the semi-finalists were China, India, Japan and Africa- hardly strongly represented here.
- Female directors are poorly represented. Only 1 of the critics is female
- I would have liked more from Japan
- The book has a British editor, who is an excellent writer and programmer, and the critics are from UK and US, hence the full chapter of 15 films on UK
- Good to find a couple of early Chinese classics, and 2 by Oliveira (3 from Portugal)
- There are some refreshing unexpected selections, and the missing major masterpieces and usual suspects don’t need promotion
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Click Here for more information.