It represents the ultimate triumph of the Sundance scam: Make a heartless home movie, get enough critics to blurb in near unison "scary," and watch the suckers flock to be fleeced. This fictional documentary within a pseudo-documentary form may be the most overrated, under-financed piece of film to come down the pike in a long time. Incidentally, when did "scary" become the highest commercial accolade a movie could receive?
Andrew Sarris
August 16, 1999