Para uma melhor experiência no MUBI, atualize seu navegador.

Betyg & recensioner

  1. K-rito's rating of the film Papirosen

    Muy buena cinematografía en los planos actuales, escenas en donde estimo debe haber sido difícil meterse con una cámara, por más familiar que seas, porque son cosas muy conflictivas. Me imagino un gran esfuerzo en registrar eso con esa calidad, y es lo que más rescato.

  2. German's rating of the film Papirosen

    Una película semidocumental básicamente aburrida, destinada quizás a satisfacer el interés del propio director y sus allegados, pero definitivamente no del público en general.

  3. carf's rating of the film Papirosen

    Perdón,pero no entendí.si la intención de la película es mostrarnos la neurosis familiar, originada por la guerra, tengo que aceptar y decir que sí, aunque la abuela del director, víctima directa, me pareció la menos neurótica. el resto de la familia,madre mía,agresión y mala onda permanente.En fin. si la intención fue otra, porfi alguien que me la explique. gracias y perdón de nuevo.valoro cualquier hecho artìstico.

  4. Guido's rating of the film Papirosen

    A Linklaterian experiment taken to reality, the lines between fiction and docummentary completely blurred. When the drama hits this characters, which are pretty much real, it acquires new meaning, and it hits HARD. Solnicki takes his time developing this, and instead of filming his family in a simple way, he tries to make it all feel aesthetically complex and cinematic. Amazing exercise in capturing reality.

  5. Pegarange's rating of the film Papirosen

    The director seems to overestimate how interesting his subject is - which is pretty natural with such a personal one - and ends up making a film that only sometimes manages to grab the viewers' full attention. The feeling of authenticity is precious, but the chaotic narrative fails to use its potential.

  6. hemachandra's rating of the film Papirosen

  7. Kevin Matthews's rating of the film Papirosen

    What could have been an interesting documentary instead falters just before the halfway point, before then collapsing down to something that is almost a chore to finish. Which is a great shame.

  8. Juan Javier's rating of the film Papirosen

    Aparte de la escena con las canciones de dos ancianos judíos polacos, en un ruidoso restaurante barato de Sudamérica, casi todo lo demás es o innecesario o excesivamente largo.

  9. captainfez's rating of the film Papirosen

    Like your own argumentative home videos only without the personal resonance.

  10. LibertyCapz's rating of the film Papirosen

    Intimate, heartfelt and absolutely beautiful, this little documentary about a Jewish family and some their trials and tribulations. Thoroughly enjoyed this.

  11. Simon's rating of the film Papirosen

  12. tinderness's rating of the film Papirosen

    Berührend ist der Film nur dort, wo er die Beschädigungen durch die Vergangenheit aufzeigt. Ansonsten wirkt er trotz der kleinen Katastrophen einer mit sich lieblos umgehenden Familie recht bald langweilig, Ich frage mich nach dem Rationale des Filmemachers, der uns auf unangenehme Weise zu Voyeuren macht, Damit instrumentalisiert er nicht nur die Darsteller sondern auch die Zuseher. Insgesamt ein unangenehmer Film!

  13. Slappy McGee's rating of the film Papirosen

    Starts off pretty strong and I found myself fully engaged in this terribly dysfunctional family and their various bickering, fights and other antics. It becomes very repetitive and obnoxious and it's obvious that the director is trying to force in deeper "meaning" with family film footage. Also, there are no likable family members and that's a problem. I was a bit underwhelmed by where this ultimately ended up.

  14. James Kastrantas's rating of the film Papirosen

    J'ai réalisé ma famille ne parle jamais des guerres qui les a amenées à ce pays après j'ai regardé ce film.

  15. zenSolo's rating of the film Papirosen

    Gracias desde el fondo del corazón, Gastón. Mazel tov y los mejores deseos para todos tus proyectos.