For a better experience on MUBI, update your browser.
191 betyg

They All Lie

Todos mienten

Regisserad av Matías Piñeiro
Argentina, 2009
Drama, Romantisk


A group of girls and boys in their twenties settle in a country house that seems completely isolated from civilization. One of them writes a novel while the others try to become a gang and prepare a robbery; some fall in love, or seem to be, or believe (or say) they are in love.

They All Lie Regisserad av Matías Piñeiro

Utmärkelser & festivaler

Buenos Aires Festival Internacional de Cine Independiente

2009 | Vinnare: Distinction to Best Argentinian Film (International Official Selection)

2009 | Utmärkelser International Official Selection


[Piñeiro’s] movies flow in a volatile fashion, and do not offer any resolution or answers to problems. With the absence of distinct plots, the director leaves room for ensemble acting, cinematic staging and topographical narratives. They All Lie is a perfect example of a plotless, but reflective film, that doesn’t need to be wholly understood to be enjoyed.
April 01, 2015
Läs hela artikeln

Vad säger folk?

  • josé neves's rating of the film They All Lie

    Another fluid and smart "contemporary"movie, with the correct influences to make "different" and"interesting, which led a curator and film critic who presented the session to evoke Max Ophuls, just in case that the traveling shots would indicate another author on the head of the unsuspecting viewer. The biggest liar here, in addition to programmers and critics, is the director himself.

  • Jesse Furgurson's rating of the film They All Lie

    I'm going to have to see this again (preferably with better subtitles) to have more than a hazy idea of what it all adds up to, but on a moment-to-moment level this is pretty wonderful, and suggests Viola wasn't so much a breakthrough for Piñeiro as a further refinement of an already fully-developed sensibility.

  • Karthik's rating of the film They All Lie

    A drier Rivette redux (rehash?) - with the references to & concern with national politics, the conspiracies, the theater, the literariness etc.- but here far more schematic, more plotted & pieced. Narrative has become an abstract geometry of motives, even character (so important to Rivette) is reduced to trope (white lady, doll etc) and the mystery feels slightly mass-produced. Still enjoyable and thought-provoking.

  • emlomm's rating of the film They All Lie

    Se nota el germen de Matías Piñeiro, la constante y consabida base de todas sus películas. Pero “Todos mienten” es demasiado cruda, no está lo suficientemente pulida. Es la semilla en bruto. Esto lo ha mejorado en sus siguientes filmes.

  • ADZERTY's rating of the film They All Lie

    Un film incroyablement "chorégraphié", tout en mouvement, imprévisible ! Je n'ai pas tout compris mais ces menteurs me sont apparus comme des jeunes individualistes, à la personnalité bien affirmée, très créatifs et merveilleusement aptes à vivre ensemble. Ils font plaisir à voir.

  • TheGaijinRoaming's rating of the film They All Lie

    Hmmm... Maybe it's just me... The subtitles were bad (I'm versed in Argentine Spanish) and even the diction/sound recording was poor (I watch these films pumped through a proper old-school HiFi system). In spite of this I stuck through it... Reading over the synopsis it doesn't seem like I missed anything, so perhaps this one just missed me. If I ever come back to this one day, perhaps it will mean something. Or not!

  • Leco's rating of the film They All Lie

    A movie that didn't say anything to me. I guess the only thing keeping me from rating it ★☆☆☆☆ is that I've liked the location... I wanted more, though. I won't abandon the idea of watching the latter Matías Piñeiro's films, but it's outta my own will, not because of this piece.

  • simparent's rating of the film They All Lie

    Absolutely fantastic. This is like a Pynchon novel, I kept telling myself. Really clever with the episodic touch and the complex interrelations between characters. Minute after minute, you wonder if there is a plot at all, if it is all organized, or if it's just a weird bunch of nonsense.

Relaterade filmer