Lighting the Darkroom: Ira Sachs on Peter Hujar’s Day
Thirza Wakefield
Peter Hujar worked magic in the darkroom, drawing unexpected things from film negatives. In Peter Hujar’s Day, a loving tribute to the New York photographer, that keen-eyed attention is turned on the artist himself. Thirza Wakefield speaks with the film’s director about translating artistic energy and community to the screen—and surprising himself in the process.
Ira Sachs has made a close study of New York, and he isn’t done looking yet. Across three intimate, 2000s-set dramas, Keep the Lights On (2012), Love Is Strange (2014), and Little Men (2016),the Tennessee-born director explored politics of belonging in his adoptive home. But if these films transected New York, lodging along the x-axis of a city famous for its verticals, his latest film tunnels down, picking out a rich seam in New York’s layered history. Adapted from Linda Rosenkrantz’s book of the same name, Peter Hujar’s Day (2025) dramatizes a conversation between the writer and her close friend, Peter Hujar: one of the twentieth century’s most important portrait photographers, and a nexus between the queer avant-garde art scenes of the 1960s, ’70s, and ’80s. When, in December 1974, Rosenkrantz asked the artist to give a detailed account of the previous day, Hujar responded with spirited commitment. But the revelatory transcript was lost for almost 50 years. Found among Rosenkrantz’s notes at the Hujar archive, the text was published by Magic Hour Press in 2021. Extending that feat of retrieval, Sachs’s film stages the day of the taping, casting Ben Whishaw and Rebecca Hall as the devoted friends. Their quietly compelling, intelligent performances lift this strange exchange off the page, and lay a trail of evidence—from room to room of an apartment on the Upper East Side—of both Hujar’s capacity for work and, what’s more important, their mutual affection.
As a realization of transcribed audio, Sachs’s film is a work of translation. But it’s also filled with smaller acts of interpretation. Hujar’s curiously annotative speech brings home how much of our everyday exchanges are readings: data gathering, conjecture. “That was my guess,” Hujar says, qualifying his impressions of the poet Allen Ginsberg’s living arrangement. The photographer makes an art of the noncommittal remark, hedging when he cannot be sure. Occasionally, he comes over professorial: “You’re assuming something that we don’t know.” It’s one of the film’s more surprising pleasures that this master of the image should take so sober an interest in language and spoken syntax: “She said, ‘A big kiss.’ There was no beginning to that sentence.”
Hujar’s insistence on accuracy—his way of protecting the project’s integrity—is one of many proofs of his friendship. And this is, above all, a film about friendship. That the photographer died at the early age of 53 is, inescapably, part of the film’s DNA. Loss envelops this short, 76-minute feature, even as it restores its artist friends to languorous animation, and brings their art alive for a younger generation. It’s encoded in the day-to-night arc of the film, its curving toward darkness, and in their succumbing to tears at the film’s moving conclusion: more emotion than is called for in that moment.
A unit in the West Village’s Westbeth Artists Housing Project stands in for Rosenkrantz’s apartment. Her actual home on East 94th Street, where the original conversation was held, was a short distance from the Hayden Planetarium. Displays of galaxies and supernovas have been projected onto the domed ceiling of that darkened room since the 1930s—a busy decade, incidentally, for Joan Crawford, Hujar’s favorite actress. This film owes something to that place’s atmospherics, its illusory magic. With Peter Hujar’s Day, Sachs brings the sun up once more over a lost New York. Moreover, he gives his subject a little of that longed-for Hollywood treatment. By his own admission, Hujar had always wanted to be—in his precise words—“some kind of star. Or a star.”
Calling from New York, Sachs talks inspiration, intimate relationships with place, and taking an archaeological interest in New York’s cultural history.
Peter Hujar’s Day (Ira Sachs, 2025)
MUBI: Where did you first come across Linda Rosenkrantz’s book?
IRA SACHS: I was in Paris shooting Passages [2023] with Ben, and I walked into a gay bookstore and saw on the shelf this small, thin text called Peter Hujar's Day. By the time I got to the last page, I was thinking, I should make something of this, and I should make something of it with Ben. So the idea to make a film was connected to our collaboration, which I wanted to continue, but also a shared interest in queer artistic history, biography, and inspiration. I reached out to Linda Rosenkrantz (I actually found her on Instagram). It ended up taking about a year before we ironed out the rights. Soon after that, we began to put together the film.
MUBI: And what was it about this text, specifically, that made you want to put it onto the screen?
SACHS: I’d been very interested in—and moved by—Peter’s work since the early 1990s. But it was the intimacy of the text and the way in which its veracity and verbatim style put me into a different time. It also brought me close to this almost romantic friendship between two individuals, which felt very familiar to me. I now have a bit of that with Linda, and that relationship has been a very nice part of this project.
MUBI: Your film presents Rosenkrantz as an artist in her own right. Has it led her to reflect on her own work, or revived an interest in past projects?
SACHS: The film revives what was really her artistic practice. Linda wrote a novel in the late 1960s called Talk, based on recordings of a few friends over the course of a summer on Fire Island. This verbatim audio translation was an art form she was developing. The interview with Hujar was one of several she did at the time. None of them were published until 50 years later, when the Hujar transcript was discovered among her typewritten notes about the conversation in the Hujar archive, which is held at the Morgan Library & Museum here in New York.
Peter Hujar’s Day (Ira Sachs, 2025)
MUBI: A number of your films are set and filmed in New York, and you’ve lived there since the late 1980s. Has the process of making of this film, and spending time in Hujar’s world, altered your relationship with the city?
SACHS: It’s a continued curiosity I have for the history and detail that’s layered on buildings and experience here. There are so many layers in New York. I’m often across the street from the building where Peter lived on the corner of Second Avenue and 12th Street. His apartment was above a theater (now a cinema) that was the home of Yiddish playwrights and performers in the early twentieth century. So there’s this endless set of experiences that somehow come one upon the other. And they include my own experience as a gay man making art, here, in the wake of a disappearance of a generation, which I still feel is very much alive in my imagination and in my work.
MUBI: The noise of New York filters into the apartment in the film. Did you source those sounds? Were they a mixture of archive and new recording?
SACHS: I worked with a sound designer named Eli Cohn to create a kind of fabric of city life that is sound-based. I’ve no interest in being accurate to period, but the film references some changes, like the particular sound of ambulances or sirens at that time. So no, it’s all new, all created.
MUBI: There are some memorable passages of movement through space in your films, often outdoors: Tomas haring off through Paris on his bicycle in Passages; Joey skateboarding alongside a new friend at the end of Love Is Strange. How, then, did you feel in the first instance about staging this mostly static conversation—
SACHS: I felt panic! I was in this state of utter panic—
MUBI: I’ve written here in my notes: “Was that alarming to you at first?”
SACHS: Oh my God… And it wasn’t clear to me how treacherous this was until I took two stand-in actors to the location with the intention of doing some advance blocking. Within twenty minutes, I thought, There’s no reason for them to move… What am I going to do? And then I thought, This is disastrous, because you have two people with a tape recorder, so you can’t justify the amount of movement that a film needs. In the finished film, you see a few things I invented that were useful: a teakettle boiling; someone needing to close a window because of the sound of a jackhammer. Ben at some point needs to get a second pack of cigarettes from his coat, which is at the door. These were all excuses for movement, but they weren’t enough in themselves. After three weeks of this cauldron of fear and creativity, I saw that I could use the ellipsis as a way of allowing movement. I could use time and the cut as pretexts for changing location. It may look like it was inevitable, but it was not—in the sense that I couldn’t see it until I had a series of photographs that I’d taken over time in the space that we were shooting. I was looking at those photographs in the middle of the night when I realized that there was a movie in that sequence.
Peter Hujar’s Day (Ira Sachs, 2025)
MUBI: Was this your first time making a film about people already known to the public? Did that change how you approached things at all?
SACHS: Well, it’s funny, because I’m in the apartment where I’ve lived since 1999, where I went through a ten-year relationship. Not long after that ended, I made a film called Keep the Lights On. It was about the history of that relationship and, at least initially, I was the inspiration for the central protagonist. Ultimately, I felt very liberated to do whatever I wanted with that story, including casting a Danish actor in the lead role. So you’re always leaving the real and moving into a new real—which is what you’re shooting and what’s in front of you. Similarly, in this case, I had little concern for being factual or correct. A lot of people around me had a good amount of concern, which meant many things were almost accurate, but again, I was always like, It doesn’t matter. That’s partially why I was interested in not only filming the text, but drawing attention to the film’s making with self-reflexive elements.
MUBI: To what extent did you manage your actors’ understandings of their characters?
SACHS: I created a bibliography of characters and places: some audio and photographs that Ben, particularly, could refer to. That being said, the way he spoke these names into being, transformed them into an actual, living cast of characters for Hujar, was extraordinary to me. That ability to bring them to life, based on only fragments, is a kind of genius. I remember working with the actor Chris Cooper once, and he had a sentence to say that began, “When I was young, I…” And I said to Chris, “When the character says, ‘When I was young,’ I think he means more aged nine to ten than aged thirteen to fourteen.” And Chris Cooper looked at me and said, “Got it.” And the next time he did it, he was a different age. It was visible somehow. And Ben had that with this material, making every phrase and every image dimensional.
MUBI: Your film shows us what it looks like when two people are comfortable in each other’s company: the atmosphere it arranges. At the same time, their conversation is not a natural one, and shots of Linda’s tape recorder remind us that this is an interview. I’m interested in how you achieved that balance between their easy intimacy on the one hand, and the artifice of the whole enterprise on the other?
SACHS: Well, there are two major artifices. One is Linda taping Peter. The other is the artifice of the film, which has a quite complex set of artificial intrusions, let’s say. As for the representation of friendship, both Rebecca and I were aware that it’s very significantly a story about losing a friend. And much of that Rebecca really wrote on her own with her performance. For me, it had to do with the emotional arc of the film bending toward nighttime and disappearance. For her, it was about arriving at a point where she could both embrace and let go of her friend, who would soon be gone.
Peter Hujar’s Day (Ira Sachs, 2025)
MUBI: The process of placing dialogue around the apartment: How did you go about that?
SACHS: There was a John Cage–like randomness to it, honestly. I wasn’t often considering what they were talking about when I thought about where they should be talking about it—except in that last scene by the window. At a certain point in a scene, I would think, This is as much stillness as the film can bear. We need to move. I need to cut. And we’d set up another. When the pair of them are talking about Joan Crawford and Bette Davis on the bed at night, and there’s this playful, sensual intimacy between them? It just happened that way. When they’re on the terrace as the sun goes down talking about the nature of making a print? Also random. But certainly I’m interested in how space and light change the way we speak to each other, and may even change the physical nature of a relationship.
MUBI: At the end of the film, we see Hujar overcome with emotion. I can think of a number of reasons why that might be (the colossal effort of the exercise, what it’s brought up for him), but the feeling also seems bigger than that one moment. Can you describe the filming of that scene, and your intentions for it?
SACHS: I have two things to say about it. One, he’s sharing his doubt. The ending recognizes the place of doubt in the course of a creative life, and how there is this circular conversation that one has around doubt and confidence. Once I was done making the film and I became the audience, I found it extraordinarily comforting to hear Peter Hujar, who seems indomitable, talk that way. I was like, And you? Peter Hujar? You, too? I experience a lot of doubt, so I really think for the rest of my life I’ll return to that moment, and draw comfort from it.I don’t think there are many films that really tell the truth about what it is to be an artist.
MUBI: And the second thing?
SACHS: The other thing I would say about the end of the film is that I was thinking very specifically about a wonderful scene in Suddenly, Last Summer [1959], which is a film by Joseph L. Mankiewicz based on a Tennessee Williams play. Elizabeth Taylor is sitting in a chair at the end of that film and talks about what happened “suddenly, last summer,” and it’s completely artificial. It’s utterly theatrical, and it’s—
MUBI: —melodrama?
SACHS: No, I don’t call it melodrama, because I think it moves beyond melodrama and achieves truth. So for both me and Ben, there was—in that last scene—an interest in Elizabeth Taylor. And that inspiration meant we went into a space that was no longer completely tied to the real. The emotions that are coming out there come from memory and history and a longer story, which also—in this place—includes his imminent death.