A matriarch’s need for a transplant from a blood relative brings a reunion of the volatile Vuillard family at Christmas. Yet a simple family gathering can’t begin to describe the unpredictable, emotional experience of this magical drama that’s equal parts merriment and melancholy.
This film is not currently playing on MUBI but 30 other great films are. See what's now showing
Stylistically, it's all over the place. It switches to telescopic view for no apparent reason. The actors talk to the camera, both in the scene and in a studio. There are scenes that are similar to those 'Previously on ...' which summarize events a bit too quickly. Overall, the stylistic changes serve to obfuscate the plot to the point where I no longer cared.
Un film bon mais trop long sur des gens compliqués. 1re min: "Mon fils est mort & je n'en éprouve aucun chagrin". 5ème min: "Avec les années je ne supporte plus mon frère". Avec un tel début, c'est mal barré ... Good filmaking about a family of weirdoes. 1st min: "My son is dead. I looked within myself without feeling any grief." 5th min : "Over the years I could not stand my brother." Such a start is bad beginning.
In the 45 minutes I endured of this, I was reminded of James Wood's essay on "hysterical realism," a sub-genre of novels in which "there is a pursuit of vitality at all costs." However, Desplechin never grasps vitality; there is only the wearying pursuit.