American Horror Story: Hotel

The Macho King

A step in the right direction after Freakshow and especially Coven. Love the setting and the mood. My main criticism's is the whole detective Se7en-esque thing going on with and the execution of the "twist" you could see happening 1-2 episodes in with who was doing the murders. Evan Peters absolutely steals the show here- Other end of the spectrum Chloë Sevigny was horrendously bad & the most wooden i seen from her.

Mugino

Essentially "The Shining" meets "The Hunger". The production design is dazzling, but there isn't enough meat to these borrowed tales. The crossovers to the earlier seasons struck me as lazy rather than creative.

Katya Kazbek

I would forgive everything for Denis O'Hare's Liz Taylor. Her picture with a turban, reading Das Kapital, is to this day my facebook cover picture.

Chichago_

I used to love American Horror Story. This particular season got none of my interest to finish the whole season.

vladimirbalt

Dennis O'Hare and Sarah Paulson kicked it out of park! Fantastic performances. Lady Gaga was a surprise. A lot of great eery energy to make it unforgettable but kinda manages to be forgettable.

Matthew Catanzano

Wow, I really love and hate this season. Gaga and O'Hare's performances were both amazing. As with the first season, the story goes nowhere and ends abruptly. It looks great, it is filmed well, acted well, there just isn't much substance here. The best AHS was certainly Asylum. (I've not seen Coven or Freaks, I started Coven and found it laughably thrown together)

Linda

Lady Gaga really deserved that Golden Globe, she is magnificant in this season! But when does Evan Peters finally get acknowledged? He gets better and better every season!!

Diderot

The best chapter in the series, thanks mostly to Sarah Paulson, Denis O'Hare, and a wonderful comic performance by Mare Winningham. (There are also some great slow-motion walks by Gaga.)