From the time John J. Macreedy steps off the train in Black Rock, he feels a chill from the local residents. The town is only a speck on the map and few if any strangers ever come to the place. Macreedy himself is tight-lipped about the purpose of his trip.
This film is not currently playing on MUBI but 30 other great films are. See what's now showing
in a word, lame. it's the old HIGH NOON plot but with better personnel. dialogue strains for didacticism but just fizzles and spurts. the whole movie is just A + B + C = "cinema of quality" — also, yet another film where Robert Ryan's unique capacity for psychological complexity is mostly squandered on a rote villain. Sturges' direction is sturdy tho. eh, extra half-star for an odd little gag with a fire hose.
Even after multiple viewings, I can't quite jump on board in calling this film a masterpiece. It's a good film, with some great visuals, a strong atmosphere of tension, and solid performances. But it's also heavy-handed with its messages, built around a predictable central mystery, and looses steam well before the end. Maybe it had more of an impact in its day, but I personally don't think it holds up very well.
One of the most intelligent moments of CinemaScope and an eloquent example of how insightfulness can pop out of the screen through dialogue. And there is Spencer: his sweetness, his bigger-than-the-screen magnificence.
Sturges builds up slowly but surely the tension and the mystery without much dialogue in this political western. Where it is question of Pearl Harbour and racism. Where it also could well be about senator Mc Carthy. Spencer Tracy, again, rightfully casted here. Love the no-rythm and anti-spectacular aspect of this one.
Solid film. This is the Tracey/Ryan show, as the actors do their best to steal scenes from one another. A lot of this film is subversive and about buried secrets. I feel like the TV show LOST took a lot of elements from this movie when initially fleshing out "the others" in S2. I really enjoyed it. Def a 50s film, possibly a slight commentary on the blacklist. 4.5 stars
This film certainly has a good cast but I felt somewhat disappointed after watching it. I felt like I was watching theater. It felt ... well ... unnatural. The action scenes were not well done and some of the acting was over the top. If it wasn't Sturges with this cast I would have taken this one for a low budget film. Sturges directed some great films. This was not one of them. I expected more. Average.