This could have been outstanding. Some of the shots were very interesting, like the one of the children coming out of the crack in the side of the house. I was overcome by a feeling of sadness after seeing this mainly because Burnett has an interesting eye, but sadly the story wanes at times and never really finds its stride. Perhaps that's the genius of it, the mood and tempo somehow reflecting it's chemistry?
A film quite unlike any other that you'll see, with a keen eye for ways of using reverse tracking for profound dramatic effect - isolation within family and community. This is crisply shot in b&w, yet is hampered by the poor quality of some of the performances. Has a deeply unsettling way with casual violence - kids torture one another, a brother abuses his kid sister, a father beats his boys, etc.
'This bitter earth, what fruit it bears'. Dinah Washington's song couldn't be more apt in this indie classic looking at an extended family getting by. Famously made for about 5K as an UCLA student thesis film it withstood the passing of time and is now rightly regarded as an essential piece of American cinema history. Poignant, thoughtful, mesmerizing and timeless.
It's the kind of movie I really wanted to like, and a lot of that was well-earned... The soundtrack is perfect. Some scenes are genius. Others, though, were kind of flat. Sadly, by the end, the lacklustre bits had tainted my final impression more than I'd hoped. Still, a significant film; well worth watching. 3.5
Más que un testimonio sobre los suburbios, "Killer of sheep" es un testimonio sobre la frustración y el desgano. El personaje principal de Burnett recuerda a los personajes deprimentes de Antonioni. La mirada de este filme no es nada neorealista ya que su mismo sujeto no posee aspiración sino decepción. Hasta la misma sexualidad se encuentra suprimida. En paralelo, un aire documental se teje. Pueblo y estereotipos.
I've seen the film three times now. This last time it seemed to me like a precursor of In Vanda's Room as if directed by one of Vanda's neighbors. Burnet knows what he is filming as deeply as any director has known what she or he films. Exquisite depth of field shots allow you to enter a world and strip away your preconceptions. Some of the acting is subpar but it hardly matters. The dance scene kills me every time.
Truly melancholic forms construct a beautiful representation of the afro-american community in a Los Angeles ghetto. But some incoherent aesthetic choices (the somehow artificial dialogues, the extra-diegetic music and the general bad acting) compromise the hyper-realist tone of the film and ruin lots and lots of otherwise potentially great scenes. The result is a flawed curiosity.
A fascinating panorama of African-American life in LA...its solitude must have been the seeds of DGG's "George Washington". Each film portrays a group tragically bound to their poverty, unable to escape it---unable to call it something. They just live; work, raise children, get in fights...and try to survive. I love the documentary aspects of the film with the pasting of do-wop over the images. Loose & Undemanding.
The fact that it doesn't feel like you are watching professional actors is refreshing and a large part of why this film works. None of the characters seem to know that every activity they engage in is the equivalent of skydiving into an unlit cave. Death, or worse, a life altering disability, seems to be waiting around every corner. I loved it. Watch it.
Good film overall - very real, thought I was watching a docu at one point... I have to say though - The daughter stuck out for me even though she was more or less in the background doing what children do best - The scene where she's singing along to the tune on the radio...get's me everytime!
Didn't love it as much as I wanted to but I have to admit that it's extremely impressive. I think its one of those films that's more important than it is great. The cinematography and use of music was perfect. The use of the song This Bitter Earth was some of the best use of music I've ever seen. I think the super realistic feel sometimes worked for the film strongly and sometimes worked against it. Overall very good