It had its OK moments and it had its great moments - there were times when Turturro's witty irony cracked me up, and others where it shot off into pure silliness. But if anything, I enjoyed the experience.
Took me by surprise when James Gandolfini broke into song and I enjoyed it. The dancing is not exceptional but there is heart to the story and there are no small parts. Minor characters shine too, which I suppose is the perk of having actor turned director - he knows the struggle of actors getting one-dimensional roles.