It was fun, and felt more like Star Trek than any other Star Trek show. My only real complaint is that Harry never got a promotion, and when future Harry's a captain in the finale, he's captaining a ship called the Rhode Island. Never got any damn respect.
Good as an introduction to "Star Trek" for non-fans but it is hard to care about the plot when one can jump onboard this show in it's first or last season and not a single character has changed it's personality or overall story since it started. Worst is the fact that the characters are so one-note that it is better when the cast get to play different versions of themselves. Also where was the conflict and trauma?