Maddin, working with his Forbidden Room collaborators, set himself the challenge to remake Vertigo without using footage from the Hitchcock classic, creating a “parallel-universe version,” in his words.
This film is not currently playing on MUBI but 30 other great films are. See what’s now showing
3.4 More of an homage to San Francisco than Vertigo, this mash-up of old films & 70's TV shows leans heavily on Karl Malden & Michael Douglas. It's the kind of thing I've gotten used to seeing on YouTube. Lots of great tidbits here from films I love, and a lot of TV clips I don't care for as well. A lot of nostalgia but nothing important, compelling or original (other than a great score performed by Kronos Quartet).
Cinematic essentialism in the same glee-&-mischief filled way as Doggiewoggiez, Poochiewoochiez. But Maddin & Johnsons work like alchemists of tone/feel/ meaning, extracting those things and freeing them from their stultifying trappings! Releasing them back into the great creative pool. A work of democratization! Sans Soleil alongside a 4 minute no-speaking Chuck Norris montage.* 4.25
Metaphysical rhythm that suppose to dance on the screen is distracted by unmerciful slash of editing and disharmonious structure. To me, Maddin's excellence comes from tangible traces of imagery, not from sit-down fat ideas.