Working with his most celebrated actor, Toshiro Mifune, Akira Kurosawa’s faithful adaptation of Maxim Gorky’s classic proletariat play keeps the original’s focus on the conflict between illusion and reality.
This film is not currently playing on MUBI but 30 other great films are. See what's now showing
Talkative and boring filmed theater in a setting of the Stone Age, when there was only a roof with 1 hole to let the smoke out .... a kind of old Hatetful Eight without Morricone ------ Du théatre filmé bavard et ennuyeux dans un décor de l'âge des cavernes, quand on n'avait qu'un toit avec 1 trou pour laisser passer la fumée ... une sorte de vieux Hatetful Eight sans Morricone ...
I'm not kidding, that dance scene at the end is one of the funniest things I have ever seen! Other than that, a really good film, solid script filled with interesting characters and I really liked the fact it only used two locations. Although partially flawed it is still a very good film. 4/5
A beautifully composed film, with thoughtful staging in depth and excellent characterisation. The bleakness of its vision is significantly at odds with the lighter tone of the -also excellent- 1936 Renoir version. Worth getting both films in the Criterion DVD set.
I don't know how to rate Kurosawa films any more: it's simply not possible for them to be passable or below average (a 3-star or lower on my scale) but there are so many gradations of vision, skill and talent between the 4-star and 5-star. This is one of my least favorite selections from his filmography but there's a cynical wisdom driving it, conveyed through words as sharp as a tack.
The great Kurosawa uses two locations,ensemble acting at its best and creative editing to involve us in this cruel,mostly hopeless world.
Fun to see Toshiro Mifune (greatest screen actor ever) as a petty thief.
There is a masterstroke to the movie in the way the characters are portrayed, where each one of them might represent a state of mind and the cast as a whole convey the primary spectrum of human emotions, completing the metaphor of the film as the tribulations of a single human mind, as a multidimensional ying-yang instead of several individual problems unrelated to one another. The lower depths of our own existence.
Kurosawa, très bon comme toujours...
Un éclairage effrayant sur la nature humaine, sur la mesquinerie et la médiocrité mais aussi sur la détresse et les comportements qu'elle engendre.
On en ressort pas avec la foi en l'homme...
Mais le moment est beau, bon et générateur de réflexion