Two French beggars, present-day pilgrims en route to Spain’s holy city of Santiago de Compostela, serve as narrators for an anticlerical history of heresy, told with absurdity and filled with images that rank among Luis Buñuel’s most memorable. A hotly debated work from cinema’s greatest skeptic.
This film is not currently playing on MUBI but 30 other great films are. See what's now showing
The Milky Way is a very transitional film from Buñuel & screenwriter Carrière, showing the way towards the free-form, fractured narrative approach of Discreet Charm and Phantom of Liberty. But the density of philosophical ideas—about the strange way logic, faith, and carnality fall into uneasy coexistence—is fascinating and delivered cheekily. Not the best place for a newcomer to start, but worth it for acolytes.
Yes, it's educational. Buñuel's lesson in Catholicism, pointing out the flaws- or dogmas- they are expected to believe. It's a concept that works in some parts and doesn't in others. It may be the weakest film from his late period. Overall, It lacks comedy and charm, and it is too dry to work well with the range of audiences his other films have. Only the most intellectual (catholic) ones could appreciate it.
Felt more like a lesson on Catholicism than a Buñuel film. Perhaps I wound have enjoyed it more had I been raised Catholic. But yeah, some good scenes, but overall I didn't really find this film to be particularly entertaining at all. I pretty much agree with what RAMOSBARAJAS wrote below me. No humor, no charm and pretty dry overall. Not bad by any means but I expected a lot more from Buñuel!
Uneven and ultimately unsatisfying religious satire from Luis Bunuel. There are only a handful of clever absurdist moments, but mostly it's just slow-paced and blandly talky, and not particularly funny or profound. Maybe it has greater impact if you come from a Catholic background, but it was lost on me - maybe I just didn't get it.
Katolik Hıristiyanlık içerisindeki dogmaları net bir biçimde eleştiren, hatta çoğu zaman dalga geçen avangart ve de sürrealist bir yapım. Özellikle polis-peder sahnesi hem tarihsel, hem de dini açıdan çok hoş alegorilerle beslenmiş.
A picaresque decimation of religious myth and mythology, fanaticism and piety. Unleashing his characteristic blend of mordant wit and ribald humor, Buñuel strikes a fatal blow on behalf of skeptics, atheists, and so-called heretics everywhere, forever securing his place in the annals of rationality.
Deux débonnaires vagabonds partent en pèlerinage de Paris à Saint Jacques de Compostelle et vont faire de bien curieuses et révélatrices rencontres dans leurs longues pérégrinations à travers le temps, l'espace et la pernicieuse religion judéo-chrétienne ..... www.cinefiches.com