While these lists are always subjective, for the most part (with perhaps a few exceptions) I’ve excluded films that were:
1. Critically derided at the time but have since gained significant contemporary critical and popular followings, such as the masterworks Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me (1992) (d. David Lynch) and Showgirls (1995) (d. Paul Verhoeven).
2. Originally received widespread critical and award recognition but are now largely forgotten, including the brilliant Running On Empty (1988) (d. Sidney Lumet), Hopscotch (1980) (d. Ronald Neame), The Three Musketeers (1973) (d. Richard Lester) and Presumed Innocent (1990) (d. Alan Pakula).
Underrated films not listed on MUBI: Sitting Target (1972) (d. Douglas Hickox), Man on a Swing (1974) (d. Frank Perry), Slither (1973) (d. Howard Zieff)
Honourable Mentions: The Missouri Breaks (1976) (d. Arthur Penn), Silent Partner (1978) (d. Daryl Duke), Switchback (1997) (d. Jeb Stuart), Just One of the Guys (1985) (d. Lisa Gottlieb), 52 Pick Up (1986) (d. John Frankenheimer), Fandango (1985) (d. Kevin Reynolds)Read less