For a better experience on MUBI, update your browser.

Nilai & Ulasan

  1. dionysus67's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Steeped with Guitry's rapid monologic approach to storytelling, this comedy of manners (and mores) seems to be deprived of cinematic vision. Indeed, many of the ranting segments of instruction verge on the theatrical as little care seems to have been places on sets and background semantics. Yet, there is a pleasure to be conveyed with the acrid dialogues, which turn to a pragmatic and vitalist (but male) manifesto.

  2. LeDobermann's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    An example of translation error in MUBI's subtitling: at 1:34:05 the father says “Maurice, regarde moi!”, but the subtitle says “Paris, [...]” (in English, Spanish and Portuguese).

  3. Matheus Falcão's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    "Minha dor é perceber Que apesar de termos Feito tudo o que fizemos Ainda somos os mesmos E vivemos Ainda somos os mesmos E vivemos Como os nossos pais" Belchior.

  4. Leonardo Mattei's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Why no one told me this guy was so funny?

  5. Tarsis Ribeiro's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    meu primeiro filme do diretor, e qual brilhante é esse rico retrato da paternidade e do crescimento, seja ele em que tempo for, como o salão ou os cenários de jogo metafisico. repleto de diálogos extensos e engraçados. Legião Urbana e Elis Regina me veio a mente muitas vezes nessas questões e relações de laços parentais. cuidem bem dos pequenuxos!!

  6. Guilherme Tristão Martins da Rocha's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Comédia de costumes. É puro teatro filmado e o argumento é uma bobagem 'burguesa': quiprocós amorosos de gente abastada. Mas os atores estão excelentes numa atuação cheia de maneirismos, que enfatizam o cinismo e ironias de um texto afiado e engraçado, cheio de 'filosofices' sobre o amor e a vida. Puro 'divertissement'. MERECE SER VISTO!

  7. Sonia Marybel's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Me gusta mucho el director , Comedia seria y plena de enseñanzas , los hombres son todos iguales en diferentes épocas, los consejos e ideas. Las miradas de los personajes y la escena de la mujer que 20 años despues quiere volver es única.

  8. easternicko's rating of the film My Father Was Right

  9. Jason's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    A father is a fossil in real time. And naturally we are talking about Guitry time, tending toward curious destabilizing expansions the more vigorous the efforts to compress it, the whole parlour game a metaphysics. My A.A. sponsor and good friend Paul—who died about a year ago—was married more than once, yet he and I were capable of spending hours mutually astonished that couples ever get together in the first place.

  10. Wesley Pereira de Castro's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Defendê-lo em relação à teatralidade é irrelevante: seu estilo vai além disso, possui especificidades interseccionais muito próprias. E geniais! Os diálogos rápidos, as atuações apaixonadas, a grandiloqüência dos ensinamentos familiares são insignes. O desfecho é um tanto rasteiro (ficamos querendo mais!), mas os jogos de olhares e falas entre o diretor e sua então esposa Delubac são imorríveis! (WPC>)

  11. Bilouaustria's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    It is as usual with Guitry full of funny lines and clever words. Believe or not he directed no less than five films in 1936. But this one is the exact opposite of the wonderful « Le roman d’un tricheur » made the same year. It was game between sound and images, written in the langage of cinema. This one is clearly a play adapted later for the screen. It is nevertheless a solid film that could have been even more.

  12. Dan Kenneth Gigernes's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    If one don’t go too deep into the strange husband/wife relationship at the end (did she actually leave because she did not want to have anything to do with her son - even in his adult years???) this is a likeable story of how a lone father try to guide his son into the right direction even if the boy has been destroyed by his mother’s choice in a way that he almost can have a normal relationship with a woman.

  13. chanandre's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    [MUBI] (larmes) -> "Elle est là par hasard. Alors allez la chercher par hasard " - aahah

  14. Pok's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    3.5 En esta ocasión, Guitry agrega un poco de drama a su comedia pero sin perder humor ni ligereza. Me resulta inevitable pensar que la sutil misoginia subyacente en los personajes (justificada por la trama) es reflejo de la no tan sutil misoginia imperante en la época (que no tiene justificación). Aún así, ha envejecido bien y sigue siendo una divertida comedia de enredos a la francesa.

  15. tubbssw's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    A staged comedy, although heavy on dialogue, is witty at times and not too long.

  16. AEDR2's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Difícil criar a un hijo, sin que su animadversión por las mujeres le avasalle. Muy teatral.

  17. plobo64's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Délicieux film, les dialogues sont excellents, les acteurs exquis.

  18. bettycelorrio's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Teatro en el cine, podríamos decir que caracteriza su obra. Diálogos y tomas prolongadas, es otra característica de su cine. Comedia parecería ligera pero con enseñanza de vida

  19. Martín Gil Navarro's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Brillante la primera parte, en la que el personaje de Sacha habla con su padre. También muy bueno el reencuentro con su esposa. El resto de la película está por debajo.

  20. Marvin's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Theatrical, but worldly and poignant. I adore Sacha Guitry!

  21. josé neves's rating of the film My Father Was Right

  22. FISCHER's rating of the film My Father Was Right

    Une nouvelle comédie de moeurs, fort allègre et bien enlevée, comme seul le toujours étonnant Sacha Guitry sait les trousser, avec charme et brio... www.cinefiches.com