The Forgotten: Never Explain a Mystery, Never Wake a Sleepwalker

The surreal travels of a pearl, a thief, a sleepwalker, a young man and his lover. Watch the entire short film here!
David Cairns

At around the time that the Vicomte de Noailles was dabbling in film finance with Cocteau's The Blood of a Poet and Buñuel's L'Age d'Or, another aristocrat, the Belgian duke Henri D'Ursel, adopted a pseudonym to direct and star in La perle (1929), a short surrealist fantasia owing much to the twin influences of Murnau's Nosferatu and Feuillade's Les vampires.

It's a charming and elegant (and slightly sinister) piece. We're told that the surrealists admired Feuillade partly because they saw his serials without the intertitles, which had been lost, so the plotlines, already oneiric and chancy, became even more opaque, transforming from linear thrillers into a random series of outrages. D'Ursel, following Murnau's lead in The Last Laugh, has only one letter and no intertitles at all, leaving us to more or less invent our own narrative to make sense of the dreamy events he depicts.

This much is certain (sort of): a pearl is harvested from the ocean in a Méliès-like bit of phony underwater action and is attached to a necklace. A young man buys the string of pearls, but a sexy female thief steals them. And then ensues a series of dreams, erotic encounters, mysteries, and indeed the whole thing may be embedded within another dream, and we are free to invent further dreamers outside the film who may be dreaming it, or even dreaming us.

"My Lulu, I had bought for you the most beautiful of pearls. It was stolen from me and I offered it to the thief herself out of love. You cannot forgive my unforgivable weakness. And I hope that you sleep without pain in your garden, without pain and without believing your eyes, Georges."

The sudden appearance of a female somnambulist stalking the rooftops in her nightgown is genuinely startling, even though it's derived all too closely from Nosferatu. The thief in her latex catsuit deliberately recalls Musidora as Irma Vep, but it's interesting to note that (a) The 1910s were already exotically nostalgic in 1929 and (b) fashions in body shape mean that Musidora's eye-openingly outlined breasts have no real equivalent in the age of the flapper, but Kissa Kouprine (also featured in several of L'Herbier's art deco romances) makes up for that with her slinky jazz baby frame and enticingly trim buttocks, straining against their membranous covering.

The whole movie simmers with sex and kink, from the leering close-ups of stockinged thighs, to the giallo-like homicidal impulses that seize the hero. D'Ursel said he made the film "in the flush of inexperience," and one wonders if the obsessive focus on what Preston Sturges called "Topic A," albeit filtered through every kind of fetishistic displacement, was simply the attempt of an artistic young man to stage a few scenes in which he could interact intimately with glamorous women.

Whatever the excuse, the result is an alluring, at times beautiful and eerie objet d'art. I do hope it got him laid. D'Ursel promptly retired from active filmmaking, but ran avant garde film festivals in Brussels: this was his only movie.


The Forgotten is a regular Thursday column by David Cairns, author of Shadowplay.

Don't miss our latest features and interviews.

Sign up for the Notebook Weekly Edit newsletter.


Henri D'UrselThe ForgottenVideosColumns
Please sign up to add a new comment.


Notebook is a daily, international film publication. Our mission is to guide film lovers searching, lost or adrift in an overwhelming sea of content. We offer text, images, sounds and video as critical maps, passways and illuminations to the worlds of contemporary and classic film. Notebook is a MUBI publication.


If you're interested in contributing to Notebook, please see our pitching guidelines. For all other inquiries, contact the editorial team.