We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Click here for more information.

Review: Surviving an Age of Crumbs—Patrick Wang's "A Bread Factory"

An ambitious two-part film by independent director Patrick Wang delves into the drama of running a community art center in upstate New York.
Leonardo Goi
A Bread Factory
“The kids need a future,” a city council member tells Dorothea (Tyne Daly) half way through the first of Patrick Wang’s two-part A Bread Factory: “they need to learn about the world.” Forty years prior to the exchange, Dorothea and her partner Greta (Elizabeth Henry-Macari) bought a bakery in the fictional upstate New York town of Checkford, and turned it into the Bread Factory, an arts center the married couple has fought hard to keep afloat through the years. Cash and funds have historically been finite and resources volatile—but while stage director Dorothea and actress Greta powered through the decades with indomitable determination and grit, the creation of a bigger arts institute in the opposite side of town, led by a couple of world-renowned Chinese performance artists, May Ray (Janet Hsieh and George Young), is poised to spell the end of the Factory’s illustrious work. The center runs on educational subsidies the town now wants to pump into the glitzier, more fashionable newcomers’ institute—a move that underscores the possibility that the Factory may have ceased to fulfill its educational functions, never mind Dorothea’s indignant defense that “kids learn about the world here, too.”
Following up on In the Family (2011) and The Grief of Others (2015), writer-director Patrick Wang’s latest feature—I use the word in the singular even though A Bread Factory’s two parts, “For the Sake of Gold” and “Walk with me a While,” stand alone as perfectly independent two-hour films—is a riveting, one of a kind cinematic experience, an ethnography of a community told with a profoundly compassionate eye that speaks to Frederick Wiseman’s Ex Libris: The New York Public Library (both in its documentary vibe and its ode to a pedagogical institution somewhat at odds with a hyper-digitalized world) and Robert Altman’s A Prairie Home Companion (of which it echoes the painfully melancholic and tragic elegy to a long gone era—and a long gone audience).
Fierce and passionate Dorothea and her empathetic, Finland-born partner Greta may well take up the longest screen time, but the multi-character canvas grants everyone their own place on stage. There's Sir Walter (the late and terrific Brian Murray), a veteran British actor who’s played in many of the Factory’s productions; Jean Marc (Philip Kerr), a retired Pulitzer Prize-winning critic who once dared to give a poor review of Walter’s craft, causing a 50-years-long silent feud between the two; Jan (Glynnis O’Connor), a local reporter replete with no-nonsense swagger and generous, mother-like advice for her only intern Max (Zachary Sayle)—a paid internship, as she likes to remind him after handing him his first check: “you don’t see many anymore of these anymore”; Max’s fling Julie (Erica Durham) a promising young actress who falls for a Hollywood star visiting Checkford to support May Ray’s cause; Teresa (Jessica Pimentel), a waitress asked to fill in for Julie once she abandons the Factory to start a career in Hollywood; the kids who take afternoon classes at the Factory (with special kudos to a  Cinema Paradiso-like Toto, Simon—Keaton Nigel Cooke—a 10-year-old projectionist), Jordan (Janeane Garofalo), an experimental filmmaker with very little patience for boring post-screening Q&As and even less for self-proclaimed creatives with no love or passion for their craft; May and Ray’s institute’s administrator Karl (Trevor St. John), a man with a few shady connections to the city council and a firm belief in his clients’ vision (“this is history,” he corrects Sir Walter after the latter interrupts a performance by the power couple to ask “what the fuss is all about”); and obviously May and Ray themselves, a duo whose performances are didactic enough to leave the audience with the impression that “they have got the message” (even when the message feeds on faux-conceptual bullshit as trite and banal as “stumbling is a part of walking,” or “down with the hierarchy of furniture!”), and who certainly do know how to throw a marketing campaign for the ages, handing out merchandising in the form of tote bags and cute, Instagram-friendly photos of the audience literally walking in the artists’ shoes.
And of all the questions A Bread Factory raises—from the present-day relevance of community art spaces to artists-propelled gentrification, from the volatility of public funding for the arts to the David vs. Goliath struggle between independent arts center and giant corporate-backed art institutes—it is the Factory’s pedagogical service to the youth that strikes me as possibly the single most interesting component of Wang’s project.
Dorothea is right: the Bread Factory is perfectly equipped to teach Checkford’s kids about the world—in fact, it can do a far better job than May Ray could ever hope to. The shows and artwork the Factory promotes do not promise short term thrills or a tangible reward—like a tote bag or an artsy selfie—but a more arduous and far more fulfilling experience, one that engages with the brain instead of numbing it under the false pretense of conceptual art reduced to prêt-à-porter statements. “Everyone cries when they make movies,” Jordan warns a class of primary school kids during their first lesson in filmmaking, and the most important thing is the passion you put into it: “next time you pick up a camera, care about it.” It’s a message diametrically opposed to the alleged engagement May Ray never truly establish with their audience—a dialogue between artists and public that fails to take off even during Q&As, themselves frustratingly hermetic performances where the two artists blast prerecorded applauses and cheers to silence the audience’s tepid responses, mouthing inaudible words in lieu of answers.
Making art presupposes pain and self-discipline, just like understanding it requires a conscious effort to embrace the inconvenient truth that its message may hardly ever be parceled out in the shape of easily digestible snippets of wisdom or Instagram-friendly one-liners. It’s a lesson that resonates in Dorothea and Greta’s acting coaching, at once rigorous and compassionate, as when they train newcomer Teresa, or when Dorothea hands a script to heartbroken Max and invites him to read on stage, with a nonchalant “things look different from here,” two among several other moments of ineffable wonder during which Wang manages to capture the mystical sense of escapism that comes with embracing one’s character, and the therapeutic qualities the transformation can offer. 
And while the mentor-pupil like relationship between veteran journalist Jan and budding reporter Max falls outside the Factory’s jurisdiction, it retains its fundamental premise: care and work hard for what you wish to create and appreciate. There’s an extraordinarily heart-warming passage when Jan catches her promising aide red-handed: Max has just churned out a sloppy article on the new May Ray institute for the local paper, effectively copy-pasting from the press release the couple handed out. But instead of rubbing the disappointment on his face, she warns Max “not to run away from the moment,” and dispenses two memorable lessons: “always be on the lookout for what you do not know,” and “words have to mean something—if they don’t, then conversations built on those words cannot possibly mean anything.” 
Though the teachings can be read as an oblique rebuttal of May Ray’s pretentious fluff, it is interesting to see how the Factory’s kids assimilate them—at times to unspeakably tragic extents, others to rollickingly ironic ones, as when Simon complains to his mother that a chicken can’t just be good, it must be great (“next time you make a chicken do it like you care about it”), or when Max singlehandedly helms the newspaper after Jan disappears in mysterious circumstances, hiring a bunch of elementary schoolers to help him cover local news and manage the advertising, in a delightfully Wes Anderson-esque game of children-turned-adults. 
A Bread Factory
If A Bread Factory’s first part follows Dorothea and Greta’s efforts to fight against a hipstery, pretentious new neighbor, the villain anchoring the second part is a far more elusive beast. With May Ray momentarily out of the picture and the school funding secured (at least for the time being), the two women can finally generate buzz for their new production, Euripides’ Hecuba, in hopes to strike a full house for the premiere. But securing an audience turns out to be just as heart-breaking and difficult a feat as securing the town’s funding, and when the curtain draws on a near empty theatre, the defeated look Dorothea wears begs a fundamental, if unspoken question: what’s the point in fighting for a cause people do not actually seem to care about?
The disorienting feeling of loss runs parallel to an exhilarating explosion of theatrics outside the stage. A local bar becomes a hotspot for mysterious tech workers (an appendix to the gentrifying artists) with a passion for tap dancing and a tendency to perform while flicking through their smartphones (one chap in particular shows off his footwork while swiping on his screen, the routine alternatively furious and excited depending on the direction of the swipe, in what one can only assume is some form of tap-Tinder); a quartet of real estate agent brokers turns into a Greek choir chanting to cajole Dorothea into selling her barn, retiring, and enjoying her last years globetrotting with Greta.  
Once contained in the finite space of the Factory’s stage, the art made therein spirals outside, springing balletically in a series of absurdist ruptures between truth and fiction that bring to mind some of Roy Andersson’s scenes in A Pigeon Sat on a Branch Reflecting on Existence. Admittedly, the constant blurring between cinema and theatre is a leitmotif that runs through the whole of A Bread Factory, and that the film feels and looks like a play owes as much to Bekka Lindström’s excellent production design (the interiors reminding one of theatre sets) as to Wang’s ability to recreate, both through script and directing, the feeling of a black box theater—the camera almost imperceptibly zooming in on the characters until everything else around them is eclipsed, the exchanges written and delivered as monologues, with faces becoming canvasses in their own right.
Director of Photography Frank Barrera films in Super 16mm, a choice that helps strengthening contrasts and saturation, but also symbolically echoes Dorothea’s anxiety vis-à-vis a world that seems to have lost interest in traditional means of representation, and a community for whom the Factory, once a rite of passage (everyone in Checkford ends up starring in one of Dorothea’s plays, we are told) has ceased to have much meaning. 
A Bread Factory is a film of quiet pleasures; it does not unfurl as a rigidly structured three-act plot, but a tapestry of memorable vignettes, gags, conversations, and heart-to-hearts. Its strength does not reside on action-packed story—though things certainly do happen, and drama abounds, if one cares to listen—but in the immersive quality of Wang’s filmmaking, and his effortless ability to capture everyday life down to its simplest, most natural facets. It zeroes in on a small community and an even tinier arts center, but it understands both so well that its scope far exceeds the confines of a fictional city in upstate New York, and by the time Dorothea and Greta “walk together for a while,” the whole town trailing behind them in a Fellini-like coda, the feeling is to bid farewell to old-time friends after a long overdue catch up. A Bread Factory may open up more questions than it provides answers (What happened to Jan? Will the Factory survive? Will Dorothea and Greta finally give up?), and that’s precisely what makes it cinema at its most humanist peaks. After all, to borrow from Jordan’s rant after a failed Q&A, “if you have a soul, you have questions to ask.”


ReviewsPatrick Wang

Related Films

A Bread Factory, Part One: For the Sake of Gold
A Bread Factory, Part One: For the Sake of Gold

A Bread Factory, Part One: For the Sake of Gold

Patrick Wang
Please sign up to add a new comment.


Notebook is a daily, international film publication. Our mission is to guide film lovers searching, lost or adrift in an overwhelming sea of content. We offer text, images, sounds and video as critical maps, passways and illuminations to the worlds of contemporary and classic film. Notebook is a MUBI publication.


If you're interested in contributing to Notebook, please see our pitching guidelines. For all other inquiries, contact the editorial team.