Daily Briefing. Cahiers du Cinéma's Top Ten of 2011

The DailyCahiers du Cinéma

The actual list of the top ten films as chosen by the editors of Cahiers du Cinéma is not online, but the cover of the December issue with the ten titles swirling in some sort of electrified vortex into or out of "2011" is. I've looked around for the order and, if and when I find it, I'll revise accordingly, but for now, in alphabetical order:

Update: Thanks to Dimitri Biniaris, we now have the proper order — quite a few ties here. See his comment below.

David Edelstein's year-end list of ten films is alphabetical, too, so, as it happens, it begins and ends with Spielberg, running from The Adventures of Tintin through War Horse. The list is part of New York's "Year in Culture" package and is accompanied by a brief piece in which Edelstein addresses the question, "What does it mean that the world ends again and again onscreen?," and a briefer one that finds him exclaiming, "Curse you, Meryl Streep!"

The Guardian is running a big batch of its critics' "cultural highlights 2011," including Peter Bradshaw's lists of the best films, directors and so on. Hard to tell if these lists are meant to be in order, but if so, he quite likes Michel Hazanavicius and The Artist. More interestingly, Margaret comes in at #2 but Kenneth Lonergan doesn't make the list of best directors.

One more list for now: Gorilla vs Bear's albums of 2011.

 

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

In other news. David Denby's review of David Fincher's The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is not online [Update: It's now publicly available], but it's out in print in this week's New Yorker and that has ticked off producer Scott Rudin. Sony showed the film to members of the New York Film Critics Circle on the condition that they would honor the review embargo date, December 13. In an exchange between the producer and the reviewer, Denby argues that the embargo put a crimp on the magazine's editorial calendar, and besides, his review is positive. Rudin: "I appreciate all of this, David, but you simply have to be good for your word. Your seeing the movie was conditional on your honoring the embargo, which you agreed to do. The needs of the magazine cannot trump your word."

The Playlist has the full exchange and a string of comments follows; Anne Thompson predicts we'll see other reviewers breaking the embargo soon enough.

Meantime, as Angela Watercutter reports for Wired, you can download a free 35-minute, six-track sampler of Trent Reznor's score. "But wait, there's more!"

2011 Awards and Lists Index. For news and tips throughout the day every day, follow @thedailyMUBI on Twitter and/or the RSS feed.

Responses

10 responses to this post.  Join the discussion

  • Anton Williams

    Love Cahiers :*

  • Daniel Kasman

    Super 8?

  • Dimitri Biniaris

    here is the top10….just received my cahiers at home in london today…
    1. we have a pope
    2. the strange case of angelica & the tree of life
    4. outside satan & essential killing
    6. melancholia & a burning hot summer
    8. super 8 & house of tolerance & meeks cutoff

  • David Hudson

    Many thanks, Dimitri!

  • Ronald

    Was the cover inspired by Duchamps Anemic Cinema?

  • John Lehtonen

    Surprised that Eastwood and Spielberg’s efforts didn’t make it.

  • DT

    Maybe they haven’t come out over there yet.

  • John Lehtonen

    Yeah, I realize that my post was not thought through very well.

  • Luis Fernández

    Spielberg’s has (late October), Eastwood hasn’t.

    And it’s not like Eastwood is a permanent feature in the Cahiers’ lists: only one of his last five films have shown up there, and it was the critically-acclaimed (at least in Europe) “Gran Torino”.

    As for Spielberg, only one Cahiers’ top-10 mention in his entire career. I don’t see how it can be a surprise.

  • Ryan Krahn

    For what it’s worth:

    That Summer – Pretty good. #12 on my list
    Essential Killing – Also not bad, but it’s from LAST YEAR*
    House of Tolerance – Amazing film. #6 on my list
    Meek’s Cutoff – Another amazing film, but also from LAST YEAR*, my second favourite film of 2010
    Melancholia – Brilliant film. #2 on my list
    Outside Satan – I was underwhelmed. Hadewijch was much better.
    Strange Case of Angelica – Very disappointing. And, you guessed it, from LAST YEAR*
    Super 8 – didn’t see it
    Tree of Life – overrated kitsch
    We Have a pope – didn’t see it.

    *What is up with lists and not being able to determine what year it is. If anyone should have access to seeing films the year they are premiered, it should be the Cahiers critics, no?

    @Jack – Eastwood’s film was, in my humble opinion, the worst film of the year by a mile.

Your opinion

Please login to add a new comment.